MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Metering problems
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

hi there
i have some problems with my camera metering when i use manual lenses
if i use them at full aperture there is no problem but if i go for f 5.6 or beyond the camera metering sis overexposes or underexposes never right(with every metering sis)
the problem appeared when my C/Y adapter chip broke down and i got an err 101(clean the lens contact's) or something like that after this i removed the chip .
can the chip adapter mess the camera metering system ?


Reply

Is this on your 40D?

If so, what metering option are you using?

Do you have some examples to post?

I have some chipped and non chipped adapters and mine seems to meter ok with either. Can you test with another adapter?


Reply

yes is my 40D
the problem happens at all metering option's randomly.
it firs happened with my C/Y adapter when i started the camera i got an err
to clean my lens contact's after i did that the camera did start but the metering was going wild (like the camera did know what to do it was flickering between 1/8000 and 1/125 very very fast , so no shutter release
when i got home i decided to remove the chip) out of 5 img only 1 is exposed correctly

ill try to make a test and post them


Reply

Do your other lenses work ok? I'm just trying to find out if it's a camera or chip fault.


Reply

The problem is well-known for the 40D and other Canon 1.6x crop cameras. All of my lenses behaved exactly as you described on my 40D: more or less normal metering wide open and severe overexposure stopped down. Apparently, AF confirmation chips partially mitigated the problem (e.g. I was still getting overexposure on most lenses, but not by as much as without the chip).

This is believed to happen because of the larger circle of light produced by 35mm lenses than required to cover the cropped sensor; there've been reports on people who managed to fix the problem completely by putting something at the back of the lens to reduce the light circle. Have a look at http://www.penta-club.ru/forum/index.php?showtopic=41859 (it's in Russian but there are lots of pics so it is easy to understand what has been done and what has been achieved).

That said, full-frame cameras (e.g. Canon's 5D and 5D mkII) do not exhibit this behavior with manual lenses, with or without the chip.


Reply

That's a smart idea.

With the risk of hijacking the thread, does anyone have any suggestions as to how to stop my Sony alphas UNDER exposing past f5.6?

Thanks


Reply

today i had done some test's an i have the same problem only when i go past f 5.6 to f 8 the camera (canon 40D) overexposes.
is this a normal behavior for DSLR'S when used with manual lenses ?? Question
what i want to ask is everybody that uses crop sensors experiences the same problem as aoleg said?

by the way thanks aoleg i was thinking that my camera is broken
thanks everybody


Reply

This is my personal workaround, I use evaluative metering and set the exposure compensation two points in minus direction (manual page 93). Save this setting to C1, C2 or C3.
Activate the histogram, for better evaluation.
Hope this helps.

PS: changing the focussing screen to a manual katzeye screen helped alot, metering is much better now.


Reply

distagon 28:2.8 without chip handeld on 40D
no exposure compensation on the 40D, untouched exposure in pp
I see more variation in auto WB than exposure
tip: I have the EE-s screen who is know to fix exposure problem
Код:

 2.8 1/250
 4.0 1/125
 5.6 1/80
 8.0 1/40
11.0 1/20
16.0 1/10



Reply

I use evaluative metering and rarely have any problems. I have to give +or- EV to a few lenses, but only a small amout and the problem is uniform.

Maybe my focus screen selection is helping (the 3rd option, can't remember what it's called)?


Reply

thank you so much everybody Very Happy
i think i will buy a katzeye screen and see if it resolved the problem
Thanks


Reply

aoleg писал(а):

This is believed to happen because of the larger circle of light produced by 35mm lenses than required to cover the cropped sensor; there've been reports on people who managed to fix the problem completely by putting something at the back of the lens to reduce the light circle. Have a look at http://www.penta-club.ru/forum/index.php?showtopic=41859 (it's in Russian but there are lots of pics so it is easy to understand what has been done and what has been achieved).


Thank you for the link. From what I can gather, it looks as if it is the same type of result (not necessarily the same cause, I realize) as using a bare VPK Miniscus lens on a DSLR. Just the masking is at the rear of the lens rather than the front.

I will have to try it with my Canon f1.8 28mm that has a LOT of exposure and focusing problems on my XTi. It is a FF lens, perhaps this will help. Please forgive me for blaspheming on this MF forum. Rolling Eyes


Reply

arhi_tectu1 писал(а):
thank you so much everybody Very Happy
i think i will buy a katzeye screen and see if it resolved the problem
Thanks


Have you checked this? http://forum.mflenses.com/custom-focus-split-screens-for-most-dslr-available-now-t16369.html

Perhaps this focus screen might help?


Reply

aoleg писал(а):
The problem is well-known for the 40D and other Canon 1.6x crop cameras. All of my lenses behaved exactly as you described on my 40D: more or less normal metering wide open and severe overexposure stopped down. Apparently, AF confirmation chips partially mitigated the problem (e.g. I was still getting overexposure on most lenses, but not by as much as without the chip).


Exactly the same with my 40D and I have an AF confirmation chip.
Wide open at 2.8 for instance : ok
5.6 : -2 stops left
8 : -4 stops left
11 : -6 stops left
16 : full left

I will have a look at what Carlsson said about metering method.

Olivier


Reply

Poilu : what is a EE-s screen ?

Merci d'avance.
Olivier
Smile


Reply

UP...

Please, what is a EE screen ?

Thanks
Olivier


Reply

Ee is the name of Canon's screen replacements.
They come in various flavours (Ee-s, Ee-whatever...)


Reply

Thanks Orio.
Smile