MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Discuss this lighting scheme
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

How would you reproduce the lighting scheme of this photograph (made by Marion E. Warren) ?



I would think of a strong spotlight placed behind high at the back of the woman, a bit on her left (photo's right)
And a main softbox light in front of her, in central position, and significantly weaker than the back light.

I wonder how there are no light reflections in her pupil.

I love this lighting.


Reply

It certainly looks as you described, Orio. This photographer shows a unique "form" and black and white images with depth.


Reply

back on hair, high on our right, further back high up front


Reply

Laurence писал(а):
It certainly looks as you described, Orio. This photographer shows a unique "form" and black and white images with depth.


Ain't that true? That Eiffel tower is magical.
I need to return to Paris. With my Contax IIa and a truck of B&W film.


Reply

Nesster писал(а):
back on hair, high on our right, further back high up front


You mean three lights? I am not sure to understand what you mean.


Reply

There's no softboxes in that shot, otherway you'd see different reflections in the glass. It's all hard and hot light, typical of the era btw.

You have two lights here, hair light above the girl's head pointing down and a spot from the right pointing at her hands. there's also probably another backlight (which I can't see reflected in the glasses) pointed at girl's backhead.


Reply

A G Photography писал(а):
There's no softboxes in that shot, otherway you'd see different reflections in the glass. It's all hard and hot light, typical of the era btw.

You have two lights here, hair light above the girl's head pointing down and a spot from the right pointing at her hands. there's also probably another backlight (which I can't see reflected in the glasses) pointed at girl's backhead.


How about the face? It seems almost evenly lit. Would it be possible if the only frontal light was a spot placed on the right?
Of course the spot on the right would explain why no reflection in the eyes.
But how to lighten the face then? Huge reflector?

If you notice, from the breast going down, it's almost dark.
I believe there must be a lighting of some sort for the front, but I am not able to tell what. Unless it's the same vertical light that is lighting the hair... but in that case, wouldn't we see terrible shadows under the eyebrows and nose?


Reply

I'd say there's a fairly un-soft light on each side to top and behind her and a reflective surface in front of the camera and possibly one one the bench.

On the other hand, it could have been done very simply with two lights and a lot of dodging and burning.


Reply

in fact the shadow on her chest has a strange shape, that does not make sense anatomically.


Reply

I think the shadow is from a baffle to give a 'weird science' look. Wink

Yes, three direct lights.

The lighting's probably a variation of the cop and the woman next to her in this guide.


Reply

Orio писал(а):
A G Photography писал(а):
There's no softboxes in that shot, otherway you'd see different reflections in the glass. It's all hard and hot light, typical of the era btw.

You have two lights here, hair light above the girl's head pointing down and a spot from the right pointing at her hands. there's also probably another backlight (which I can't see reflected in the glasses) pointed at girl's backhead.


How about the face? It seems almost evenly lit. Would it be possible if the only frontal light was a spot placed on the right?
Of course the spot on the right would explain why no reflection in the eyes.
But how to lighten the face then? Huge reflector?

If you notice, from the breast going down, it's almost dark.
I believe there must be a lighting of some sort for the front, but I am not able to tell what. Unless it's the same vertical light that is lighting the hair... but in that case, wouldn't we see terrible shadows under the eyebrows and nose?


The face is not evenly lit. There's a pretty evident reflection of the forehead caused by the spot from the right. Btw, I think the spot used it's a sort of fresnel light, very commonly used in cinema and theatre but also in still life and food (less in portrait nowadays). It is basically a circlular spot, very directional, where you can have a hard spot of light and an outer softer spot of light controlled through a focusing lens (the fresnel lens). This explain how you can have a sudden falloff of light from the breast down. Then probably there are also some reflectors in front to open the shadows.


Reply

A G Photography писал(а):
Orio писал(а):
A G Photography писал(а):
There's no softboxes in that shot, otherway you'd see different reflections in the glass. It's all hard and hot light, typical of the era btw.

You have two lights here, hair light above the girl's head pointing down and a spot from the right pointing at her hands. there's also probably another backlight (which I can't see reflected in the glasses) pointed at girl's backhead.


How about the face? It seems almost evenly lit. Would it be possible if the only frontal light was a spot placed on the right?
Of course the spot on the right would explain why no reflection in the eyes.
But how to lighten the face then? Huge reflector?

If you notice, from the breast going down, it's almost dark.
I believe there must be a lighting of some sort for the front, but I am not able to tell what. Unless it's the same vertical light that is lighting the hair... but in that case, wouldn't we see terrible shadows under the eyebrows and nose?


The face is not evenly lit. There's a pretty evident reflection of the forehead caused by the spot from the right. Btw, I think the spot used it's a sort of fresnel light, very commonly used in cinema and theatre but also in still life and food (less in portrait nowadays). It is basically a circlular spot, very directional, where you can have a hard spot of light and an outer softer spot of light controlled through a focusing lens (the fresnel lens). This explain how you can have a sudden falloff of light from the breast down. Then probably there are also some reflectors in front to open the shadows.


Thanks !!
I have a lot to learn, I really enjoy all this information.
Where did you learn so much about old lighting schemes?


Reply

Orio писал(а):
A G Photography писал(а):
Orio писал(а):
A G Photography писал(а):
There's no softboxes in that shot, otherway you'd see different reflections in the glass. It's all hard and hot light, typical of the era btw.

You have two lights here, hair light above the girl's head pointing down and a spot from the right pointing at her hands. there's also probably another backlight (which I can't see reflected in the glasses) pointed at girl's backhead.


How about the face? It seems almost evenly lit. Would it be possible if the only frontal light was a spot placed on the right?
Of course the spot on the right would explain why no reflection in the eyes.
But how to lighten the face then? Huge reflector?

If you notice, from the breast going down, it's almost dark.
I believe there must be a lighting of some sort for the front, but I am not able to tell what. Unless it's the same vertical light that is lighting the hair... but in that case, wouldn't we see terrible shadows under the eyebrows and nose?


The face is not evenly lit. There's a pretty evident reflection of the forehead caused by the spot from the right. Btw, I think the spot used it's a sort of fresnel light, very commonly used in cinema and theatre but also in still life and food (less in portrait nowadays). It is basically a circlular spot, very directional, where you can have a hard spot of light and an outer softer spot of light controlled through a focusing lens (the fresnel lens). This explain how you can have a sudden falloff of light from the breast down. Then probably there are also some reflectors in front to open the shadows.


Thanks !!
I have a lot to learn, I really enjoy all this information.
Where did you learn so much about old lighting schemes?


I have a book written by an old Hollywood lightning director, John Alton.