MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Advices from EOS 5D users
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

Hello, good evening to all.

As i said in another thread, i plan finally to save a bit money and go full frame , oh at least on DSLR anyway, for not being disseapointed by a smaller viewfinder that i have on my SLR's.

So after reading here and there, and considering the prices that are by now quite "affordable" , less than 1000€ that is, i plan to buy the EOS 5D surely nexte year.

The MP pixels are not an issue, i read that up to A4 prints and i plan to do some with a home printer, its far than ok it seems. I'll have a slr / dslr printing lab Cool

Ok, now how does it performs ? I'll have a 28-80mm lens to start, the PLanar 50mm an Sonnar , and some m42's . Good investment ? Cos i don' need a mark II with 20mp , besides its too expensive let's face it out.

Thanx for the infos.


Reply

The 5D is still a fantastic camera.
No matter the MP, I still get great pictures from it.
Last I got from it was this one:



As you can see, although now an "old" camera, if used with the right lens (in this case, a Summilux-R 50) it can still produce top quality pictures that technically speaking have enough resolution to be used for magazine covers and small posters.
It is one of those unforgiving cameras, because when you miss a photo with it, you have no excuses, it is you to get the blame Rolling Eyes Wink


Reply

The 5D delivers great photgraphs period.

I will help you with my pros and cons if you like..

Pros:

Great Raw files.
Expose right in the histogram and you can recover down up to 1.5 stops.
I have printed up to 20x30 in color and B+W.

Nice looking high ISO
Maybe not as clean as current models. The 5D gives a nice "grain" at 1600 and not too much of it. 100-400 are clean. 800 is clean enough in good light a bit noisy in shadows or in poor light.

Solid but not too heavy body

Good ergonomics
Once you shoot a couple days you have the thing down.
I like the rear jog-wheel for the exposure comp control. BTW I almost always shoot AE.

Cons:

Lousy LCD.
Poor color representation, too small, not the best for viewing in bright light, resolution at 2005 standards.

No Antidust devise

Crappy Card door

No weather sealing

Factory EEa focus screen is a must to replace.

Cheers


Reply

I'll just add to this since I'm debating on whether to get a clean used 5D or go for the 5DII:

Pros:

Full Frame image. For me, this is really important. Not only do your wide angle lenses behave like wide angles, but the viewfinder is large enough where it's possible to be accurate when focusing manually.

Cons:

No Live View. For those times when I can't focus manually as well as I'd like, LV is a real image-saver.


Reply

It's one of the best digital cameras ever made. I think the big pixels are an advantage. High ISO performance is not as stellar as the Mk2 but you can shoot to ISO 400 - maybe even 800 - with zero noise if you are very careful with the exposure.

I never had an issue with the card door and I managed OK with the original screen.

The one big issue was sensor dirt. The high pass filter is a dust magnet and needs regular cleaning. But as I live in a desert with burning oil flares which is also one of the world's biggest building sites, I have more ambient dust around me than most.

As the 5D sensor needs occasional manual cleaning, you need to check any camera for sensor scratches (and dirt) - point it at a clear sky, stop down to f22 and take a pic with the historgram in the middle of the range then see what is there at 100% view on the computer.


Reply

Thanx for the infos an reviews all.

I don't care much about live view, lcd screen is not something that i would stare at for hours, since i'll be using the main upper screen . We can clean the dust manually i think with a dust blower ... High iso, well i think 800 will be a maximum.

Its more about having a bright viewfinder and a decent focusing screen.

I'm not that difficult when it comes to ergonomy Razz


Reply

Salut Hexi.

Here is a link to a comparison made by pro-photographer Jean-François VIBERT.
http://www.macandphoto.com/2008/10/le-grand-matc-2.html

It should interest you.

A+ !
Very Happy


Reply

Merci Olivier Very Happy very intersting read that finished to convince me ( if necessary ) , and the little cons don't disturb me at all , no live view etc .. besides i don't want to spend 2000€ on a body, i prefer to buy lenses.

As for its age, well 5 years old is nothing frightening, i have slr's that are older than me ! So it'll be my newest camera body ever.
And my fisrt DSLR Cool


Reply

Hi hexi
]

In this case -- I am speaking against 5D ----

why?

go for this camera:

Canon 1Ds Mark -- (no I, II, III -- none of these)

please, follow this link what camera I am talking about:

http://www.imaging-resource.com/PRODS/EOS1DS/E1DSA.HTM

why?

1 - no mirror issues with too many Contax lenses --
2 - it's professional camera
3 - superb built
4 - price less than 5D
5 - better diffraction resistance than 5D
prons:

maybe small display -- but I have had 20D (2.5 inch display) -- I think it's enough ...

cheers

Stan


Reply

Hello trifox

I'll consider that as well, the Contax compatibilty is important to me Very Happy
This body seems scarce nowadays ... anyway it's a good advice, thanx.

But if i can get both and compare ! Cool


Reply

There are several EOS 1DS's on US eBay right now. Bids currently under $800 on a few. BINs under $1000 on a few others. A FF 11.4mp camera for this price is tempting.


Reply

and in France there are some "announces" here :

http://www.leboncoin.fr/li?q=canon+eos+1d&ca=17_s&th=1&c=16&w=3&ps=&pe=&fu=&gb=&ct=&zz=ex%3A75001


Reply

Seen one on ebay finished some hours ago , final price 600€. Tempting definitevely, but as i said there a few, i saw more 1Ds Mark II. Nevermind ,this is indeed a great body !

No flash, no gadgetery, small LCD, no live view .... wow this is what i call a decent reflex Cool


Reply

Hexi ---

1Ds -- I was really hunting for it ...

If you see it for good price -- grab it!

The main benefit is REALY SMALL diffraction!! this camera has a HUGE PIXELS!!

highly recommended ...

tf


Reply

I was considering a 1DS recently, but had a few reservations after reading user comments:

1. Very slow operation (writing files and playing back files) - not very useful as an all round camera, perfect for landscapes or some studio use however

2. Poor high ISO operation above ISO 400

3. Small LCD

4. Weight

Unfortunately these things turned me back towards a 5D, but if you need full frame on the cheap, it's the cheapest bet and well built!