MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

CS5 & Noise
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

I've just upgraded to CS5.

Not a great deal of difference to CS4 except for masses of noise in camera RAW. Anyone else seeing this? It's hideous!


Reply

I can't actually say. i use Photoscape program and have by now bought an external CF card reader in order to avoid headache with software. I convert raws and i don't need to work hardly on them, i'm a lazy person Wink

seriously the images are ok without big processing, i don't like spending too much time pp i prefer taking photos

sorry for the OT


Reply

martinsmith99 писал(а):
I've just upgraded to CS5.

Not a great deal of difference to CS4 except for masses of noise in camera RAW. Anyone else seeing this? It's hideous!


I've recently upgraded to CS5 as well but am not having a noise issue with camera RAW. What exactly are you experiencing and can you show examples?


Reply

I always have noise reduction to 0 and I didn't see difference
maybe your default values are different between versions
you can use 'Save Camera Raw New Defaults' to customize


Reply

Well, whatever ISO I shoot with it looks really noisy. I've compared CS4 with CS5 and it's like night & day. Increased noise, or created noise.

All settings the same.


Reply

martinsmith99 писал(а):
Well, whatever ISO I shoot with it looks really noisy. I've compared CS4 with CS5 and it's like night & day. Increased noise, or created noise.

All settings the same.


Nothing like this on my version. Maybe a reinstall...?


Reply

I have gotten around it by decreasing my default sharpening. I think the sharpening may be more extreme in this version. Other than that I am puzzled.


Reply

Not quite the same, but I did notice that with LR3 beta that the noise seems hideous, but it does clean up nicely once I turn the NR on.


Reply

eccs19 писал(а):
Not quite the same, but I did notice that with LR3 beta that the noise seems hideous, but it does clean up nicely once I turn the NR on.

Yes, but turning on NR softens the image negating the sharpening. It also looks a bit fake.


Reply

It seems others have found the same too: http://forums.adobe.com/thread/659806?tstart=0


Reply

They have changed the noise engine.
Do what follows:
1) zero both noise (luminance and colour)
2) raise value of colour noise until colour noise disappears
3) raise value of luminance noise until you obtain a good balance between image detail and smoothness

If you do that carefully the results will be better than in CS4 where the luminance noise control did literally kill the image.


Reply

I preffer Capture one to work with raw images, save them as tiff and then you PS if needed. Tried Camera RAW in PS, it's not that flexible as Capture One and not so much possible options. The main disadvantage of camera raw: interface is not very user friendly and not that comfortable for raw images processing.
imho.


Reply

I've only installed CS5 a couple of days ago, so I can't comment
with any authority or even experience, but I will be following this thread
with much interest as I learn more about the program.


Reply

The more you sharpen the more you have to apply NR. It is possible to get decent results but I still prefer CS4.


Reply

martinsmith99 писал(а):
The more you sharpen the more you have to apply NR. It is possible to get decent results but I still prefer CS4.


well, it is not necessary to give up CS4 in order to use 5. I have both installed on my system.

What I am getting here is different, I get better results than CS4 with regards to luminance noice. But I agree that to start with a sharp lens is better. If you start with a soft lens and need to sharpen it a lot to look good, you'll have to fight with big noise.