MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

aperture vs lightroom 3 opinions sought
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

i have to choose between these two programs primarily for PP'ing of my canon 5d, but also for 120 slides. i am leaning towards lightroom, but it's $100usd more expensive than the aperture program. i have briefly used both and have my own initial opinions, but would really welcome others opinions of the pluses/minuses of each from member's own perspective.
thanks
tony


Reply

Hi

I tried Lightroom 3 and it's very good. As i'm not used to this kind of software, this one is very simple to use. You have one part of quick developing the raw image, then the advanced one ( develop ) with much more possibilities.

I'm using the first one, mainly for WB,conveting in b&w and adding some blacks, light, whatever; There's also an important amount of creative filters, green, red, infrared, grain, stuff ...

I highly recommend LR.


Reply

thanks hexi, that's the way i'm leaning. i am still using my 'try out' copy of aperture and i'm finding it not as pleasing to me as lightroom, but i still am looking for comparative opinions in case i'm overlooking something....


Reply

I have LR3 - before that I used LR 1.41 and before that Rawshooter. I have also tried several, if not most of the alternatives (demo versions, if commercial). I have not used Aperture - I use Windows (and Linux to test raw-converters etc.).

The develope module of LR3 is easily the most user friendly and practical of all the converters I have tried. Image quality is very good, among the best of them. Very nice feature set and ease of use.

I can't really say much about the library module. I am horrible at organizing images, and in principle this module does good job for an amateur like me. It is clearly improved from LR1.41, but it could use some refining, I think. Then again, many of the alternatives don't even have this feature.

Importing images with LR3 was hard for me at first - but by the third or so time I imported I realized how logical and nice the import dialogue is. Exporting jpg's is easy with output sharpening too.

The other modules I've not really tried, so can't telll much about them.

Anyhow, I think one should try out all the demo-versions oneself before making the decision. Also one might want to consider the open-source converters, though it seems like the most promising ones are still quite a bit 'work in progress' and the most finnished ones are hideous to use.


Reply

thanks anu. i did use the trial version of L3 and it does seem to me to offer better quality conversion on my 5d than aperture, but i was thinking that maybe i was crazy and was wondering if indeed there could be a visible qualitative difference in high level conversion programs, so i wanted to get some other thoughts on that issue. i also think L3 has better controls than A and even better organizing capability. having said that, i really value member opinions as i have only been doing this a relatively short time and want to have as much info as possible before i commit so much money to such an important part of the photo process.
thanks again!
tony


Reply

If you look at any comparison of the different RAW converters you will quickly see that there is a wide range of capabilities. Frankly, and I am not inviting a flame war, some of the most expensive are really quite poor at it (cf Photoshop). I do not use LR and have only just started with Aperture, but I use it for organizing, now that iView has gone the way of small corps that threaten larger corps (Adobe). Have you tried any other RAW converter? Why the limitation to these two - neither of which is a specialized converter?


patrickh


Reply

thanks patrick. yes i have tried some other converters that i have discounted, like silkypix. i really want the convenience of having a converter that also has organizing capabilities. i take a lot of photos and really dont want to waste time going back and forth between programs. i want to convert, edit and organize all in one.

i welcome your thoughts on such software, and if there is something i havent tried that you think i should, i would certainly give it a try.

tony


Reply

The new Bibble 5 is extremely fast, very accurate and has an organizing capability. Takes a bit of getting used to, but does a very fine job of rendering RAW accurately.


patrickh


PS They allow trial download


Reply

thanks patrick! i downloaded bibble yesterday and compared some unaltered raw conversions from my 5d w aperture and i have to say i was very surprised to find that aperture was clearly more pleasing to my eye. i had not expected that as i had understood bibble to be primarily a conversion engine with organizational software added on (vs aperture which i always thought of as primarily organizations software with added on conversion feature!)

again, this is very subjective stuff and anyone else's opinion could vary, but there was a very clear difference in the two conversions. i really appreciate your suggestion.

btw, lightroom just got a very favorable review from dp review....especially its conversion software.