MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

First Experiments with CS4 B&W
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

I took my camera, Sigma 35-80, and a pocket full of ND and polarizing filters out today specifically to get some very-long-duration shots of a small creek waterfall. While I was at it, inspired by a recent photography magazine article on B&W nature photography, I thought I might give CS4's B&W conversion a shot. However, this being the digital darkroom page, this post will focus on the B&W photos.

I took one photo series with an ND4 and a polarizing filter specifically to convert to black and white. It was the only photo I didn't think might be okay in color, too. I took three shots, all three at f4. The shutter speeds were 1/8, 1/4, and 1/2 of a second. In addition, I had photoshop stitch a photo together of the three, as an experiment, and also did an HDR merge. First, the three seed photos in order of aperture speed (fast to slow):


1/8


1/4


1/2

The contrasts and background are all as expected with the various shutter speeds. To my eye, the first is the most appealing overall because of the nice mid-tone balance; however, the bear carving on the second is the best example of the statue.

In terms of processing these, I opened the color image in the B&W filter and used the same settings for all three images:
Red: -128%
Yellow: 216%
Green: 166%
Cyan: -137%
Blue: -77%
Magenta: 100%
These values seemed to provide the best differentiation in the wood grain and added more character to the bear's face, specifically the dark lines coming down from its eyes.

So on a whim, to see what would happen, I used photomerge to make a stitch of all three. It used parts of all three images, though from the 1/4-secnd image it used only two small spots on the stump. Here was the result:


It captured part of the 1/8-second exposure's background and most of the 1/2-second exposure's statue. I would have liked more of the background from the 1/8-second exposure to have transitioned into this stitch, but in general I thought the experiment worked. I'll experiment more with this and see if it's an alternative to HDR photos, which I haven't exactly mastered.

However, I have had some luck with HDR photos in B&W. The following photo is an HDR merge of the three bear statue photos.


There was minor wood grain fidelity loss during the merge, and turning the three layers on and off resulted in varied amount of the wood grain shifting or blurring. In the end, I elected to retain all three photos for the HDR because it provided a balanced image with a good background.

All this said, many of my B&W attempts turned out to be wholly unpalatable, and were summarily deleted with great prejudice. However, I have four more photos to share from this trip that turned out with different success levels.


Pigeons taking flight. I grabbed my camera as they were taking off and didn't have time to change the settings from what they had been a few shots before when I'd been using an ND4 filter. So the shutter speed was a lot longer than I would have done, but the effect was okay. In color this shot is embarrassing. The monochrome helps slightly to hide the camera shake due to the camera being in motion and the 1/125 second exposure time.



More interesting than in color due solely to the interplay between the water's smooth texture and the bird's feathered texture, it's little more than a college-level photo assignment picture. I post this one, though, because it was a good example of how altering the various color percentages can result in a good or a bad result. For this one the warm colors needed more extreme adjustment -- red very dark and yellow very light. The cool colors needed to all be centered because, if not, the water took on a mottled, small-poxish look.


This shows a limitation of the B&W filter: the water reflections. In order to achieve the contrast I wanted around the rock and fish, the green and yellow sliders had to be positioned so that the reeds reflecting on the water became visible, an artifact not even noticeable in the color image or the unadjusted B&W. So sliding the sliders to the extremes can, on some surfaces, result in unrealistic digital artifacts.


This image would have benefited from a cloudy day. The bottom, where it's contrasty and neat looking, was tree-shaded. The upper parts were in full sun. Here moderate slider adjustments resulted in the reeds reflecting on the water in a more natural way. However, the B&W filter can't save this photo from the simple fact that it really isn't very good.

In short, I'll be experimenting more with digital B&W in the coming months. I realized today a few things: 1- I've forgotten a LOT about how much different B&W photography is from color, 2- B&W photography requires a different mindset from color photography, and 3- I was never really any good at B&W in the first place, so retraining my mind for a new style may be a good artistic exercise.