MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Got my SEL 18-55 today...
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

... which turns my beloved NEX into a point'n'shoot.

OK, perhaps not the best lens in the world, but it's AF is fast and hits.
And it's very, very quiet when focusing.

I am really happy, because that completes my NEX set in another direction.

Basic NEX-set that allows me to shoot a complete holiday and is very light and compact:

NEX-3

SEL 2.8/16 (= equiv. 24 mm)
SEL 3.5-5.6/18-55 (= equiv. 27-83 mm, so basically a 28-80)
Leica Summarit 2.0/50 (= equiv. 75 mm)
Leica Elmar 4.0/90 (= equiv. 135 mm)
Leica Hektor 4.5/135 (= equiv. 210 mm)

Fujian 1.7/35 (= equiv. 53mm, for effect pictures)

And I can add some other lenses if I want it, such as a Zenitar 2.8/16 to go really wide, etc...


Последний раз редактировалось LucisPictor Вт Авг 23, 2011 4:57 pm; всего правок: 1


Reply

wow congrats, fast AF, quiet and ... it hits!


Reply

poilu писал(а):
wow congrats, fast AF, quiet and ... it hits!


Well, that's not the case with every AF lens. Wink


Reply

Where did you buy it? They are expensive. You can get Nex-3 + 18-55mm kit for 339€ but the 18-55mm alone costs 269€ (cameranu.nl) Evil or Very Mad

My kit:
Sony Nex-3
Sony 16/2.8
Olympus 35/2.8
SMC Takumar 55/1.8
Olympus 85/2
Meyer Trioplan 100/2.8


Reply

Nice set!

Riku писал(а):
Where did you buy it? They are expensive. You can get Nex-3 + 18-55mm kit for 339€ but the 18-55mm alone costs 269€ (cameranu.nl) Evil or Very Mad


Yes, I realized that when I was looking for one.
I wanted to have one because I do not want to take my SLR gear to London in September, but I want to have a cam with a good sensor there.
And for future holidays, I now might also leave my DSLR at home.

I bought my lens on €BAY, set a bid and forgot about it and finally won.
(My bid was €1,- higher than the price I got it for.)
Good seller BTW, won it on Sunday night, paid by PayPal and today the lens arrived!


Reply

Hello, Carsten ,
Can you share a few samples , please?
It's interesting , because there are moments when AF helps and don't want to take the Rebel 400D with me .How does it perform in low light (the AF , I mean)?


Reply

Congrats, Cersten.

I keep mine and got rid off the 16mm. The focal is too close to the 18mm in this one, and the smaller size of the 16mm is not really a benefit for me. Not as bad as is reported around, I think is sharp and performs really well.

Enjoy it!.

Regards.
Jes.


Reply

yinyangbt писал(а):
Hello, Carsten ,
Can you share a few samples , please?
It's interesting , because there are moments when AF helps and don't want to take the Rebel 400D with me .How does it perform in low light (the AF , I mean)?


As soon as I find the time, ok?
The AF is not bad in low light, although this lens is not really a low light shooter with that max aperture. Wink


Reply

Perhaps Carsten you allow me to help with 2 samples from my test drive with the kit lens. I think this lens is a must at this price with the NEX.





Wink


Reply

It's actually a better lens then the Canon EF-S 18-55 IS, according to some. You can also compare them (albeit on different sensors) here at dpreview.

Also, congrats on the purchase Carsten! Wink


Reply

symphonic писал(а):
It's actually a better lens then the Canon EF-S 18-55 IS, according to some. You can also compare them (albeit on different sensors) here at dpreview.

Also, congrats on the purchase Carsten! Wink


Best cheap lenses are come from Samsung to NX series. Worth to have a SAmsung NX just for one lens.


Congrats Carsten!


Reply

Thanks, Rolf.

Yes, I really like this SEL 18-55 OSS and think it's more than just decent lens!


Reply

symphonic писал(а):
It's actually a better lens then the Canon EF-S 18-55 IS, according to some. You can also compare them (albeit on different sensors) here at dpreview.

Also, congrats on the purchase Carsten! Wink


Sorry, but I think that the Canon kit lens is a very valuable lens fot that price. Maybe most of the user can´t work with this lens in the right way. A little bit OT but below few samples with the Canon kit lens. If you can get one for a cheap price for your crop Canon try to get it.








Wink


Reply

I agree, Rolf. The (1st version) 18-55 was the first lens (along a Tamron 28-300!) I had for my first DSLR, an EOS 350D.
And although I did not like this lens for its built, I never had to blame its performance!

And still, it does not have the "feel" in order to convince me. The Sony 18-55 OSS has! Wink


Reply

Rolf писал(а):

Sorry, but I think that the Canon kit lens is a very valuable lens fot that price.


I agree completely and I think it's a very good "bang for the buck" lens. My point was only to state that the SEL1855 should be even better. I'll be transferring to a NEX (5N) very soon and I'll try to do a comparison between the two (although with the sensor differences it won't be a fair comparison to begin with, but it'll be fun and I'm just curious). Smile


Reply

Would be interesting to know whether this is the same kit lens with the new NEX-7 or if Sony will modify the lens/performance for the new cam ? On images I have seen they look identically but who knows ?

Wink


Reply

Rolf писал(а):
Would be interesting to know whether this is the same kit lens with the new NEX-7 or if Sony will modify the lens/performance for the new cam ? On images I have seen they look identically but who knows ?

Wink


Well... it's black. Wink

I don't think that they have made a new calculation, perhaps some tweaking here and there, rather in electronics than in optics.


Reply

now, after having had the lens for a while, may I ask what are your thoughts, Carsten?


Reply

kuuan писал(а):
now, after having had the lens for a while, may I ask what are your thoughts, Carsten?


I am almost ashamed to say that I love it! Embarassed

Yes, it has the typical flaws that such a zoom lens always has: there is some distortion at the wide end etc.
But all those flaws are really neglectable in pratical use. It's AF is fast and hits most of the time, the IQ is pretty amazing for such a "cheap" lens and it absolutely silent compared to my Sigma 18-125 OS for example. It even feels alright, much better than you might expect.
Actually, knowing that this is a rather good lens has helped in my decision to pre-order the NEX-7!


Reply

thank you very much for your feedback Carsten

I am to get a NEX5 ( not the 5N ) soon and I wonder if I should get it with the 18-55, the 16mm I get anyway.
I shall use my Pentax K-x parallel to the NEX, have the good Sigma 17-70 for the Pentax. The SEL 16mm on the NEX will cover my wide needs, and I have been thinking that in future better I shall carry my Sigma zoom but so far it has stayed back because I always have felt that it is too big of a lens for me and my small K-x.

Now I wonder: in future carry the Sigma 17-70, which I know you also have an like, or better get the SEL18-55 instead?
Carsten what's your thoughts on this?

best greetings,
Andreas


Reply

kuuan писал(а):
Now I wonder: in future carry the Sigma 17-70, which I know you also have an like, or better get the SEL18-55 instead?
Carsten what's your thoughts on this?



Hard to compare, Andreas. The Sigma 17-70 is built better, more rugged, and almost a stop faster (aperturewise) plus it offers more tele.
The SEL is smaller, lighter and more silent.

I would recommend to buy the set with the 18-55 if you buy a NEX. You won't get that lens as cheap later. And if you don't like it, you will easily be able to sell it. I bought the NEX-3 with the 2.8/16, because I thought that this 16 and my manual lenses would be ok. Then, when I realized that I more and more often I only bring the NEX, I wished for a "universal zoom" which only the SEL 18-55 can be. Thus I had to buy the 18-55 used for the money that I would have gotten a new one for in the kit. I was lucky, though, my 18-55 is in mint condition.


Reply

thank you Carsten, great advice!
Now already I have someone waiting for 'my' 18-55 in case I don't want it, so I shall get it and give it a try Smile