MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Problems with EVIL
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

My Pentax K-x unfortunately has been suffering from a seawater splash, and though it was fine for some months it is now behaving strangely. Maybe some contacts have corroded. There is no point in getting it fixed as its out of warranty. It is probably cheaper to buy a new one.

I have recently tried a couple of EVIL cameras - Sony NEX 3 and a Panasonic GF3 - with M42 adapters.
I am wondering whether to go there or sell a bunch more lenses to buy a Pentax K-5.

These are cheap compared to even a new K-x and of course they can adapt to any lens.

Neither had an eye-level finder, though I'm not sure how much of an improvement that would be.

Problems -

- Slow (not because of autofocus of course) - its just that I could not tell quickly when the lens was probably in focus with Live View, and the cycle time seemed much slower than with the Pentax. My style with the Pentax is to take a LOT of shots quickly while adjusting focus. Live View doesn't seem to adjust very fast, maybe because it also has to adjust exposure. Also the live view picture is not stable compared to an optical view, as the camera also isn't stable, so framing is much slower and uncertain. This is a big problem with longer lenses I think as motion of the camera is magnified greatly. These are reasons I never used my K-x live view.

- Also, when zoomed to do critical focusing, I lose the whole picture. Its like taking pictures with a magnifier on a SLR. And it seems much slower to update when zoomed. And of course when zoomed camera motion is magnified even more.

- Viewfinder brightness. I have seen the hoods for these. Do they really work ? Do they fall off ?

- Eyesight - I am cursed - I am very nearsighted but at the same time I have to remove my glasses to see close things. With a SLR I take pictures with my glasses on, I just set the diopter and everything is fine. With the EVIL's I have to remove my glasses to see the screen - when I have my glasses off I can't see the subject.

- IS in-body. I love Pentax IS. Is there any EVIL with something like that ?

- Focus confirm for manual lenses

- Carrying the camera plus lens - Usually I put a lens on the camera and hang the camera from my shoulder with its strap. I walk around with even very long lenses at my side, the Pentax are strong and they are fine to hang with a 3Kg lens attached. With the EVIL's thats not going to work as they don't have the strap lugs, and they don't really seem strong enough to hang a big lens on. I guess I would need to attach the strap to the lens somehow. There are rings I can screw into a tripod socket I suppose, but that won't help with things like a 75/1.5 Biotar.

Are there some techniques you EVIL guys use ?


Reply

Цитата:
- Slow (not because of autofocus of course) - its just that I could not tell quickly when the lens was probably in focus with Live View,


Most of the time you can tell it, well maybe not as fast as on DSLR with nice MF focusing screen.


Цитата:
Live View doesn't seem to adjust very fast, maybe because it also has to adjust exposure.


This is true about Sony yes, if you change aperture while zommed in the Live View the exposure does not compensate automatically. With Oly Pen it does.


Цитата:
Also the live view picture is not stable compared to an optical view, as the camera also isn't stable, so framing is much slower and uncertain. This is a big problem with longer lenses I think as motion of the camera is magnified greatly. These are reasons I never used my K-x live view.


True, an optional electronic viewfinder and in body image stabilization helps a bit but generally it is true.
Цитата:

- Also, when zoomed to do critical focusing, I lose the whole picture. Its like taking pictures with a magnifier on a SLR. And it seems much slower to update when zoomed. And of course when zoomed camera motion is magnified even more.


This is also true, you cannot beat the DSLR for this, eventually the focus will be more accurate, but generally it will take you more time to focus and frame a picture.

Цитата:
- Viewfinder brightness. I have seen the hoods for these. Do they really work ? Do they fall off ?

if you are talking about electronic viewfinders they are nice, you can focus even in bright light. Don't know about new OLED Sony version, i have Oly VF-2 - with the latest bodies (e-p3) the refresh rate is better , with my e-p2 it feels slow. There is accessory rubber eyecup for VF-2 (EP-9) which I'm also considering buying.


Цитата:
- Eyesight - I am cursed - I am very nearsighted but at the same time I have to remove my glasses to see close things. With a SLR I take pictures with my glasses on, I just set the diopter and everything is fine. With the EVIL's I have to remove my glasses to see the screen - when I have my glasses off I can't see the subject.


Doesn't sound very convenient .. well the VF-2 has an diopter adjustment but for LCD yes .. it is not good then.

Цитата:

- IS in-body. I love Pentax IS. Is there any EVIL with something like that ?


Only Oly pen has it, the top bodies (e-p2, E-p3) claim to have 4 stops advantage - and i agree it is working really good.

Цитата:


- Focus confirm for manual lenses


There is no such thing, or maybe you need to use an EMF chip - there were link somewhere in the forum here for af confirm chip for micro four thirds. For Sony i haven't heard.


Цитата:

- Carrying the camera plus lens.


True, you can't carry big lenses on shoulder, also you need to hold the lens not the body when taking pictures with heavy lenses.


So if you do not care about the small body and light weight lenses (which are the main reasons for migrating to mirrorless) maybe you are better of with Pentax DSLR.
If you can live with the limitations of the mirrorless cams and you pay the additional cost (for Nex 5n with oled viefinder or Nex7 or E-P3 with VF-2) you may actually enjoy them for manual focus. On the other hand the IQ also will be better with DSLR - well maybe some pics will not be 100% in focus but i guess you can also use LIfeView on the new bodies.

I'm also planning to get one Pentax Smile if i find a cheap one. - just to supplement my Oly Pen.


Reply

luisalegria писал(а):


...
- Viewfinder brightness. I have seen the hoods for these. Do they really work ? Do they fall off ?
...


Sorry to hear about the damage on your K-x. But in my opinion, EVIL is the way.

Regarding LCD hoods, the ones for the NEX are nice and keep stuck to the LCD with four clips. Easy to remove and to put on, and quite stable.

Not the same for the Olympus. They have a single pseudo-hotshoe plug that just keeps it in place in front of the LCD, but moves easily out and might break.

I do prefer the NEX over the micro 4/3 for the sensor size mainly but also for the "focus peaking" feature in the NEX line.
You can watch on the LCD where the focus is in, through a set of coloured lines that outline the areas in focus. Once you try it, no way of goback to other ways.

Regards.,
Jes.


Reply

Luis your analysis is valid, but with my NEX as base I could make another thread called 'problems' of dSLR': big, heavy, less lenses adaptable, no focus peaking, no tiltable LCD = ease of low POV asf.. In short EVIL and dSLR are different and each has it's advantages and disadvantages.

Great to have the choice, and best to base one's choice on personal use and preferences.
( e.g. I never do many shots in rapid sequence, changing focus, but try to get it right. To focus correctly is easier on my 5N than on my K-x. My eyesight means on NEX having to change less between 2 glasses and no glasses than on k-x asf..)

Since I have a NEX5N I have been using it much more than my K-x. Reasons are above all it's manual focus aids, which help much more than focus confirm of Pentax dSLR, it's tiltable LCD and EVF which give easy access to more extreme POVs, size, weight, and also because now I can use more, other 'new' acquired lenses. Since most of my photography is travel, street photography most likely I'll continue to use my NEX more than my Pentax and that even though I prefer the IQ of my K-x.


Последний раз редактировалось kuuan Чт Янв 05, 2012 12:46 pm; всего правок: 1


Reply

I use EVIL cameras 2 yrs from now, I never want again DSLR , I think best thing if you buy a used NEX-3 or Samsung NX10 if you need EV finder. Get experience with new system, don't give up at first week and if you survive first week you will love it, if still not you can sell your camera easily. Used bodies are very affordable so no risk to take a try.


Reply

You should go for the nex5n with evf.
Nothing can replace my K20/K5 combo, but i also got the nex5n lately, and it is really awesome, esp with the evf.

cons: all you mentioned and:
- The hood of evf will fall off.
- buttons too small
- control wheel, direction buttons and touch screen drove me crazy for days, still not mentally adjusted to it.
- no flash hotshoe, i have to get nex7 for it. also sony hotshoe pin displacement, cannot use center pin for radio triggers.
- less control/custom settings than k20/k5
- virtually no limitation, any lens, LBA deluxe.
- it's a sony Confused

pros:
- evf for nex5n is awesome. very good resolution. acts like canon focus screen S type, but with focus peek, and digital zooms.
- virtually no limitation, any lens.
- small size, good IQ
- touch screen for flexible focus point
- forgot: tilt adapters on nex. I ordered 8 adapters, 2 of them are tilt.


Reply

Yes this is the most scary .. unfortunately it is true Laughing
You need to be even stronger when trying to resist buying more lenses.

Цитата:
- virtually no limitation, any lens, LBA deluxe.


Reply

luisalegria писал(а):
My Pentax K-x unfortunately has been suffering from a seawater splash, and though it was fine for some months it is now behaving strangely. Maybe some contacts have corroded...


contact problems are typical problems, the wheel of my K-x started to behave strangely too ( after abt. 38.000 releases ) Often mentioned solution, and if only for some months, is using a socalled 'contact spray'. Just now I spoke to a friend who is a car mechanic and asked him if I could borrow a contact spray. He said he has a 'anti corrosion' spray which acts against corrosion and would make contacts work better again.

depending on how many problems your camera has it could be worth the try..


Reply

luis ive been through this same choice and i have the same problems you identified. i can tell you from my personal experience, without an external vf, EVIL cameras were virtually useless to me because of focus issues. again this is both my personal experience and opinion, but my ep1 without vf, focusing was just impossible on that little lcd screen, and 'screen hoods' destroy the one truly valuable assett of these camc: their portability and unobtrusiveness. if you cannot obtain or afford an EVIL cam that has a proper vf, my advice is dont get any and move to your second choice, as you will not be truly happy with either the process of focusing at arms legnth nor with the results you achieve taking pictures that way. my ep2 with external vf is like night and day compared tp ep1 without it.


Reply

rbelyell писал(а):
luis ive been through this same choice and i have the same problems you identified. i can tell you from my personal experience, without an external vf, EVIL cameras were virtually useless to me because of focus issues. again this is both my personal experience and opinion, but my ep1 without vf, focusing was just impossible on that little lcd screen, and 'screen hoods' destroy the one truly valuable assett of these camc: their portability and unobtrusiveness. if you cannot obtain or afford an EVIL cam that has a proper vf, my advice is dont get any and move to your second choice, as you will not be truly happy with either the process of focusing at arms legnth nor with the results you achieve taking pictures that way. my ep2 with external vf is like night and day compared tp ep1 without it.


Don't miss the focus on the Sony NEX line. I can somewhat agree with you when talking about micro 4/3, but Sony is quite different.

Regarding the LCD hoods, it depends on the hood kind. Mine does not affect portability: I'ts collapsible when not in use.





Regards,
Jes.


Reply

Thank you everybody.

I think I will have to try some more cameras, and maybe one with an evf.


Reply

O.T.
kuuan писал(а):

contact problems are typical problems, the wheel of my K-x started to behave strangely too ( after abt. 38.000 releases ) Often mentioned solution, and if only for some months, is using a socalled 'contact spray'.....it could be worth the try..


the spray did the job for the 'wheel' of my K-x, now back to working pretty much normal Smile


Reply

Olympus is launching a new PEN soon with built in EVF Wink


Reply

Nordentro писал(а):
Olympus is launching a new PEN soon with built in EVF Wink

Cool this means i will get an cheap e-p3 soon Smile


Reply

std писал(а):
Nordentro писал(а):
Olympus is launching a new PEN soon with built in EVF Wink

Cool this means i will get an cheap e-p3 soon Smile


I still stick to my E-p1 Very Happy