MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Ultrawide for APS-C
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

The full frame bodyes are out of my reach on these days of financial crisis ... so I'll stick on smaller sensors for a while ...
Which are ,in your opinion , the best ultra wide lenses (best price/quality ratio) ,no matter the system .
My widest lens is now the 17mm Vivitar . I'd go wider even if this would suppose a zoom + a second hand body only for that wide zoom.But I won't go over 500 E . because of this streched budget , the 12 mm Heliar is out of question. I'd shoot mainly architecture with that lens .
The easiest way would be 17mm Viv + film body . But I'd like to go also at 800 ISO , and the 800 film is not cheap or easy to find now and the labs stink in my area, so I'd go digital.


Reply

the new olly is supposed to be paired with a 12-50 weatherproof zoom...

you could strap on a 16mm zenitar, with which i got great results on my olly.

a 15mm heliar can be had for less than $500 and is supposed to be killer, and tiny.


Reply

Samyang 8mm F3.5 wide enough for you at £200-230

Samyang 14mm F2.8 £220-250


Reply

I'd prefere a rectilinear lens , not fisheye .
On EOS mount , the first 12-24 from Tokina has sometimes good prices on bay ,but it's a bit heavy and big . To be honnest , the two 9-18mm from Oly seemed interesting for me , being light lenses and small also.


Reply

rbelyell писал(а):
the new olly is supposed to be paired with a 12-50 weatherproof zoom...

you could strap on a 16mm zenitar, with which i got great results on my olly.

a 15mm heliar can be had for less than $500 and is supposed to be killer, and tiny.


15mm Heliar goes deep into body I couldn't mount on m4/3.
12mm Heliar with Leica M mount fit perfectly on NEX.

Cheapest and one of the best option is Tokina 17mm f3.5


Reply

thanks attila i didnt know that about the helar 15--i was thinking of getting one, so that is great info!


Reply

Attila писал(а):
rbelyell писал(а):
the new olly is supposed to be paired with a 12-50 weatherproof zoom...

you could strap on a 16mm zenitar, with which i got great results on my olly.

a 15mm heliar can be had for less than $500 and is supposed to be killer, and tiny.


15mm Heliar goes deep into body I couldn't mount on m4/3.
12mm Heliar with Leica M mount fit perfectly on NEX.

Cheapest and one of the best option is Tokina 17mm f3.5

Thanks ,Attila , I have one , as I said the Vivitar 17/3.5 is made by tokina.But I am thinking at something wider ,to give around 17-20mm equivalent in FF . Hard to find in MF .The Samyang 14 mm seems indeed a good contender . I don't know about the distorsions because I want it for architecture.
Well, digging a little , I found that it actually has inacceptable (for architecture shooting) complex distorsion : http://www.photozone.de/canon_eos_ff/532-samyang14f28eosff?start=1
Does somebody if there is some free soft for correcting strange distorsions (moustache type) ?


Reply

Vivitar 17 perhaps not same even if made by Tokina, like Cosina make Zeiss and Leica lenses , but they are not equal with Cosina labeled lenses Wink I had many Vivitar what made by Tokina none of them reach Tokina ATX or RMC Tokina quality.


Reply

Attila писал(а):
Vivitar 17 perhaps not same even if made by Tokina, like Cosina make Zeiss and Leica lenses , but they are not equal with Cosina labeled lenses Wink I had many Vivitar what made by Tokina none of them reach Tokina ATX or RMC Tokina quality.

Well , that's not the issue . But wich wider lens ?


Reply

yinyangbt писал(а):
Does somebody if there is some free soft for correcting strange distorsions (moustache type) ?

You might try an Adobe Lens Profile. See this, for example.


Reply

yinyangbt писал(а):
Attila писал(а):
Vivitar 17 perhaps not same even if made by Tokina, like Cosina make Zeiss and Leica lenses , but they are not equal with Cosina labeled lenses Wink I had many Vivitar what made by Tokina none of them reach Tokina ATX or RMC Tokina quality.

Well , that's not the issue . But wich wider lens ?


I am afraid you want too much , low distortion wide around 20mm on an 1,5x crop sensor. Old lenses didn't made bellow 15mm and not in fish eye. Modern lenses has quiet a distortion if their price not sky rocketed. I think no good and inexpensive solution.

12mm Heliar what I did suggest is one of the good solution, but cost is around 700 USD or more. Samyang 14mm only inexpensive solution what I know, but I have no clue about it's distortion.

Use film as I do and you will have inexpensive full frame solution.


Reply

Attila писал(а):
yinyangbt писал(а):
Attila писал(а):
Vivitar 17 perhaps not same even if made by Tokina, like Cosina make Zeiss and Leica lenses , but they are not equal with Cosina labeled lenses Wink I had many Vivitar what made by Tokina none of them reach Tokina ATX or RMC Tokina quality.

Well , that's not the issue . But wich wider lens ?


I am afraid you want too much , low distortion wide around 20mm on an 1,5x crop sensor. Old lenses didn't made bellow 15mm and not in fish eye. Modern lenses has quiet a distortion if their price not sky rocketed. I think no good and inexpensive solution.

12mm Heliar what I did suggest is one of the good solution, but cost is around 700 USD or more. Samyang 14mm only inexpensive solution what I know, but I have no clue about it's distortion.

Use film as I do and you will have inexpensive full frame solution.

It's the cheapest solution probably I'll do so . The 20mm Flektogon is allready here Wink

sichko wrote :

Цитата:
You might try an Adobe Lens Profile. See this, for example.

Thanks for the link ! But it seems it works only for FF


Reply

14mm 2.8 Samyang/Rokinon/Bowers/Peleng (There are plenty of re-badges of this lens)

The mustache distortion is a maximum of a 10 second fix with a profile, or a dedicated $25 program, and it's plenty sharp, with some saying, for pure sharpness, that it beats out the 18mm and 21mm lenses.

I had a play with a friends and was most impressed. As soon as finances allow, I'll be getting one myself.


Reply

Does 17mm count as ultra-wide for APS-C? I think a modern AF 10-?? zoom would be a better solution.


Reply

Tamron and Sigma both produce ulta wide zooms, not sure of the focal ranges but widest I think is either 10 or 12mm. Both might be worth looking into.


Reply

Not mf but you could try the excellent tokina 11-16 and comes in at around £400


Reply

Thank you all for replies . In fact I am looking around for
a) Tokina 12-24 f4 ( cheaper than the 11-16 and ,for this , more fitted to my budget. But ,I'll look around for 11-16 if I find one to fit the money).I already have the EOS 400D body. (around 300E)
b) Olympus Zuiko 9-18 f4-5,6 seems it can be had for some 100 E more than the 12-24 I Toki ,in 4/3 . I'd love it because it's much lighter and smaller also . I'd need for it a body in 4/3 or m4/3+ adapter ,wich raises the price (but could bring a stabiliser )
c) Olympus Zuiko 9-18 f4-5,6 in m4/3 much smaller and lighter than the 4/3 ,but pricier (around 550-600 E) and requests a body (around 150 E) wich I don't have
d) The Sigma 10-20 f4-5,6 fits somehow in the 500 E budget . But it's a tad heavy and has some tricky distorsions .
e) Samyang 14mm ,after the information that some colleagues here gave to me about the possibility of corrections could be interesting . Don't like the big protruding front element .Can be easily scratched and it's too obvious to my taste (I prefere the more discrete lenses ) But it has a very good IQ/price ratio ,it seems ,very apealling . (around 300 E)
f) Olympus 11-22mm f2.8-3.5 a fast one but big and heavy as the Tokina . A 4/3 body adds to the price (wich seems minimum 480 E)


Reply

This thread has been interesting reading. I'm thinking of getting an wide prime or zoom and it's been useful to read everyone's opinions. Going wide is a problem with crop sensor DSLRs, isn't it?


Reply

Yebisu писал(а):
This thread has been interesting reading. I'm thinking of getting an wide prime or zoom and it's been useful to read everyone's opinions. Going wide is a problem with crop sensor DSLRs, isn't it?

You just pointed the problem. If there is no financial restrictions , the choice is easier . For example , on Canon crop body one of the best choices is the Canon EF-S 10-22 . But it runs around 650-700 E used in Europe .Lower prices in States . On Pentax ,the Pentax 12-24 or the Pentax 15 prime . On m4/3 Panasonic 7-14 ,on 4/3 Zuiko 7-14 .On Nikon ,Nikkor 10-24 or 12-24


There is ,of course the option to go the other way , buiyng a FF used body around 1000 E (EOS 1d series 8-11 Mpix ,5D ) and go with 16 or 17 mm lenses AF or MF if the weight and bulk of such a camera is not a problem (and money , of course).