MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

Vexing Buying Decisions -- which way to go?
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

Hey guys,

I'm a long-time Canon user. I still have a large collection of FD lenses and old Canon gear. But all my AF stuff is EOS. Recently, since Canon's finally come out with the EOS M, I've been thinking about buying a MILDC instead of a nicer DSLR. I mean, if I go with Canon, I can still use my EF lenses with the adapter they offer. But more importantly for me, I'll be able to at last use my FD and FL lenses on a modern Canon camera. Of course, there are all the other lenses I own as well . . .

But I wonder – if I'm gonna buy what is essentially a new system, is there anything particularly advantageous for me in staying with Canon? I mean, if you look at some of the comparison tests between the M and the NEX 5/6/7 models, it sure seems that they are formidable competition. And if I buy an M, only to watch as Canon comes out with an M Mk II a few months later which has all the features the M lacked that I wanted, how would such a situation make me feel better about being in the “upgrade path?” Oh, geez, I get to go out and spend another $800 just to stay current. Mr. Green

So I'm just kinda wondering what would you do? What would push you into one situation more so than the other? Price/Value? Name? Features? Quality of the features? I think for me it will probably come down to a suite of features each camera has that I consider essential, but which are not necessarily the same, and then selecting a camera system based on best perceived usefulness. Whatever that might be . . .


Reply

I have to ask what's a MILDC? I have not seen that abbreviation before Embarassed


Reply

i personally would not invest in any digital system without a viewfinder, especially if you intend to use manual focus lenses. i have found this is a tremendously important point to your enjoyment and proper use of equipment. you can use your fd lenses on sony nex 5 or fuji xp1 or xe1. those are the only ones i would consider as they have vfs.
tony


Reply

mo писал(а):
I have to ask what's a MILDC? I have not seen that abbreviation before Embarassed


Mirror less digital camera.

I suggest to take a second hand Sony NEX-3 and buy and LCD View finder , activate peak focus. Cost max 150-200 USD and if you not like it easy to get money back. If this is fine and you love it and really need cost effective AF setup, buy a Samsung NX something and some AF lenses , sell Canon EOS lenses for sure. All cost is not much and I doubt with multiply more expense , you can get better pictures.


Reply

Mo, I guess I made it up as I was going along, but I kinda figured somebody else would have thought of the same combination:

Mirrorless Interchangeable Lens Digital Camera

Tony, the viewfinder issue is an important one to me, and I can't help but wonder what Canon has done to make their screen more visible. I have read this, though, which tells me if I want to go the Canon route, I should just wait:

http://www.petapixel.com/2012/12/04/viewfinder-equipped-canon-eos-m-will-reportedly-arrive-late-next-year/

I haven't read any reviews yet that specifically discuss using the existing M's screen outdoors in full sun. There is the Hoodman (and work-alikes) solution, which is effectively the same as an EVF, isn't it.

By the way, I took a look at the NEX 5 models, and neither one have a built-in viewfinder. An accessory EVF can be bought for a large sum of money, however. For the price difference, though, one could just about buy a NEX 7.

And that's another thing: for not a whole lot more than the EOS M, I could get the NEX 7 with 24 mp. So, do I wait for the M mk II that's supposed to be available later this year, or go for the 7? I wonder if Sony has a 9 in the works . . . you know, Minolta's 9-series AF cameras were their top-of-the-line models.


Reply

Very Happy Thanks for the explanation...I never would have guessed.

My only thoughts on this subject is ... how itchy are you to spend money? Personally I would wait for the Canon as it seems to be your preference.When it comes out you can then choose between the Canon or the Nex....because you would have all the information in front of you on both cameras.Nowadays, I don't like buying anything new as there always seems to be a cooling off period of fixing little glitches in a new product.


Reply

Mo, I couldn't agree more with everything you wrote. I've been out of the loop for the past several months, so I didn't even know that an improved M will be released later this year until just today, when I ran across a news article on the subject. I'll bet M sales are sucking bad right about now as most interested folks are adopting a wait-and-see attitude.

Now, I'm thinking that this new M, for which there do not seem to be any speculations as to features, will be quite a bit more than an M with an added viewfinder. No, I expect a boost in motor drive frame rate, improved buffer capacity to handle all the additional pics, more AF sensors and a faster AF module, at a bare minimum. If they're smart, they'll have bumped up the resolution to about 20mp or so.

Canon really needs to take its competition in the MILDC arena more seriously, I think. Especially from the Sony NEX system. I haven't done that thorough of a features and performance check, but it sure looks to me like the Sony NEX 7 is the best MILDC out there. And watch out -- the Sony brass has already admitted that if there is sufficient demand, they can build an interchangeable lens RX1. Now that's an interesting thought. I think I'll go over there and I'll issue a demand right this instant!

That seems to be the big question on all the makers' minds right now -- what will demand be like? I've read a couple of articles that report forecasts of soft sales for the MILD type cameras. It seems that they're suffering from something of an identity crisis, that they're offering the solutions to problems that hadn't been adequately identified yet. If only they knew that it was all a nefarious plot put forward by a few whacko manual lens users, who were well positioned within the industry and who saw a way to influence the entire industry to produce a new technology just so they can use their old mf lenses with their various registration distances and proper adapters on a single photographic tool. Psst! Shhhh! Don't tell anybody!


Reply

I'd rather wait for a full-frame NEX. Reportedly, SONY already has one in development (and they already have full-frame video cameras with E-mount). Why settle for a cropped sensor if you can go full-frame? Also, your Canon lenses will work on the NEX system with adapters (already available and not much more expensive than those for Canon M).


Reply

aoleg писал(а):
I'd rather wait for a full-frame NEX. Reportedly, SONY already has one in development (and they already have full-frame video cameras with E-mount). Why settle for a cropped sensor if you can go full-frame? Also, your Canon lenses will work on the NEX system with adapters (already available and not much more expensive than those for Canon M).


+1
Chances are that the full frame nex when it comes out (and I suspect it won't be extremely soon) will be quite expensive, though.
If you can live with an aps-c sensor, for little more than the price of a eos m you can buy a nex-6 with the built in evf, that is a better option, imho.
Obviously, the more you can wait, the more options you will have.


Reply

Trouble is, there is always something new in the pipeline or on the horizon. I say get something to take pictures with now. A second hand nex is a good idea as you'll get most of your money back if it doesn't suit. Consider any loss as rental.
But then you already have something to take pictures with... Wink


Reply

I think Canon are playing catch up, but they will catch up. Until the time Canon make the camera you really want I would go for a NEX. I got mine very cheap, but brand new, about 18 months ago, I paid £250 for it all boxed up. Yesterday morning in a pawn shop I saw one exactly the same but no box, leads or software for £310, 3 hours later when I went back in for something else it had been sold. The market for used NEX seems to be very good.


Reply

hey michael-- any reason you wouldnt consider the xp1? ive seen them going used for under $800 on ebay. otherwise, i agree with the nex7. the vf thing is not just a matter of 'seeing', but of proper stabilization, being able to 'brace' the cam to your head.

my issues about nex7 vs xp1:
sony seems to me too small to support fd lenses in a balanced way;
i believe only fuji removes the AA filter, yielding much more overall clarity;
i personally think fuji has both much more realistic skin tones and handles highlights better--just my opinion.
tony


Reply

aoleg писал(а):
I'd rather wait for a full-frame NEX. Reportedly, SONY already has one in development (and they already have full-frame video cameras with E-mount). Why settle for a cropped sensor if you can go full-frame? Also, your Canon lenses will work on the NEX system with adapters (already available and not much more expensive than those for Canon M).


That was the point I was making regarding Sony's RX-1. That is the still-digicam you're referring to. And you're right -- since Sony already has released a FF video camera, I see absolutely no reason for them not to offer a still version, except for demand. But if I were Sony, I would go ahead and release it anyway, and just prepare myself for the eventuality of it being a slow-sell at first. And Sony can do as Canon did with their EF lens adapter. They can produce an adapter so that all the Alpha/Minolta AF mount lenses will fit it as well.

So, yeah, that would be the ultimate. Or maybe a Leica M10 built right would be the true ultimate. But the Sony's gonna carry what is pretty much an ultimate price tag, too. At least for me. The current RX-1 sells for about $2800. An interchangeable lens model with a standard lens will run at least that much. That's up there in 5DIII territory.

Guys your suggestions are in line with what I've been thinking. I'm disappointed with the EOS M's lack of what I consider to be important features. So the more I think about it, the more I feel it would be stupid for me to invest in an M at this point. I wouldn't be surprised if Canon's 2nd generation MILDC doesn't even meet the mark and it'll take a 3rd generation camera before they finally start addressing the needs of pros and serious amateurs. I've been a Canon user for many years and that's just the way they seem to roll. So I'm just not gonna wait any more. Going with a used NEX for now makes a lot of sense. Problem is, I don't see much point in spending money on a NEX 3 cuz of its lower resolution, the fact that it "only" does 720p video, and it doesn't have a viewfinder. Does the NEX 3 take the expensive accessory EVF? I dunno, but I know the NEX 5 does and that that is the only EVF option for the NEX 5. So if I'm gonna go with a used NEX system, I'll be looking for a NEX 5 with the EVF, or a 6 or 7.

Hey Tony, I have drooled at length over the Fuji X-Pro1 -- I assume by xp1 that's what you're referring to. I have an old Finepix 3000 -- a 3mp DSLR from Fuji that really manages very sharp pics for a 3mp camera, and it's all because of the very good lens that little camera has. I've been a big fan of Fujinons for many years. But getting back to the X-Pro1, its resolution numbers seem a bit on the low side compared to the competition nowadays and it's priced at the very top of the market for that particular class of camera. It's one gorgeous piece, though, isn't it. If I could pick one up with that 18-55 zoom for about half of what just the body is selling for new I'd be very tempted. X-Pro lenses sure are pricey, tho. I see an X-Pro1 body only on eBay right now that has a BIN of $835; its auction is up to $705 with four days left. I reckon it'll end up selling for its BIN. That's the cheapest there for now. The next closest is just a body with an opening bid of $900 and no bids. I'm not surprised. And that dinky flash that sells for $333? Kinda rich for my blood. I like the way Sony manages to build theirs in.


Reply

Okay, I think I've finally arrived at a decision:

Buy a used Sony NEX 7 with lens. Better resolution than a 5D MkIII (I know, I know, setting aside the whole APS-C vs. FF debate for now) and a very high frame advance rate of 10fps, which I can actually use. Plus, it has everything else I need and want -- articulated screen, EVF, multi-segmented metering and AF, plus a whole lot more. Looks like I'll be able to pick one up in the $800 range or so, and I think that will be a good price for my purposes.

I have a totally unrelated question. What is the point of an EOS-NEX adapter? I mean, EOS lenses have no aperture rings, so how does one control the aperture on the EOS lens? They don't, do they? So what's the point?


Последний раз редактировалось cooltouch Чт Фев 14, 2013 6:49 pm; всего правок: 1


Reply

cooltouch писал(а):

So I'm just kinda wondering what would you do? What would push you into one situation more so than the other? Price/Value? Name? Features? Quality of the features?


Use. Buy the camera system you will use the most. That depends on your needs and on your liking.
If you take a lot of portraits, go for a DSLR system, nothing can beat a reflex camera for portraits. If you like to take snapshots and candids, go for a true rangefinder system.
If you are more the "photograph during parties and vacations" guy, or the "I want to use every imaginable lens" guy, then buy an EVIL camera that is small, offers video recording and can mount MF lenses.
If you like to photograph still life, food, macro, buy a medium format camera with digital back or a large format film camera with rails that can be tilted and shifted.
There is no system that is better than others in absolute terms. There are systems that are more or less suited for the needs and wishes of a specific user.


Reply

cooltouch писал(а):

I have a totally unrelated question. What is the point of an EOS-NEX adapter? I mean, EOS lenses have no aperture rings, so how does one control the aperture on the EOS lens? They don't, do they? So what's the point?


AFAIK, there are EOS to nex adapters that actually control aperture and AF, such as metabones' smart adapter. Not cheap, but if you have some AF EOS glass it could be an interesting option.


Reply

Orio, yours is good general advice for somebody who's just beginning to think about things regarding choosing a new system. But I'm well beyond that. As I mentioned, my main reason for going with a mirrorless camera is so I can use all of my mf lenses, including my Canon FDs and FLs and M39s, of which I have a few. Now, what attracts me specifically to the NEX over all the others is its very high still capture frame rate. This is something I can use on occasion. I used to do a lot of motorsports photography and this is an area I'm interested in getting back into, especially since there have been a few very interesting racetracks that have opened up fairly close to where I live. And having a high frame rate available is more than just a nice feature with this sort of photography. I'm curious about how it will handle with a large tele, like a 300mm f/2.8. Usually when shooting with the 300mm f/2.8 or longer lenses I own, I like to use a monopod, but I've done a lot of offhand shooting with them also. I'm not concerned about the 300/2.8's balance because I've used my XS (1000D) with it quite a bit. It's not as quite as light as a NEX 7, let's say, but it's close. So I don't foresee a problem when it comes to how a NEX handles. I've played around with several different ones and I do like their heft and feel.

I've thought quite a bit about the models and which to get as a used one. I don't want a 3. If I were to get a 5, I'd get a 5R, but then I'd also have to have a viewfinder of some sort. That means either the expensive EVF option or something like a somewhat less expensive Hoodman. And an accessory flash, since it doesn't have one built in. If I go with a 6, I get the EVF and the built-in flash, but the other differences between the two -- the 6 and the 5R or 5N -- while significant, don't matter all that much to me. But it's much easier finding a used 5 than a 6, too. And since the 7 has been around a while (since August, 2011), chances are good that I might be able to pick up a clean used 7 for what I'd have to give for a new 6, or maybe even a 5 with the EVF and flash. So, according to that sort of calculus, a used 7 would obviously be the best way to go, preferably one with a NEX lens.

You know, the more I think about this whole NEX business, the more I expect Sony to release something new real soon. I mean, the 7 is a year and a half old now. What is that in people years? A couple of centuries? So, now I'm thinking I should just wait and see what the new top of the line NEX will look like. Grr. Frustration. There is this bit of temptation:

http://www.ubergizmo.com/2013/01/sony-nex-7m-rumored-to-be-the-nex-7s-successor/

And this:

http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/sr4-new-nex-7-successor-coming-in-first-half-2013/


Reply

cooltouch писал(а):
Orio, yours is good general advice for somebody who's just beginning to think about things regarding choosing a new system. But I'm well beyond that.


I simply replied to your question, which was very basic:

Цитата:
What would push you into one situation more so than the other? Price/Value? Name? Features? Quality of the features?


A basic question calls for a basic answer...


Reply

Orio писал(а):
A basic question calls for a basic answer...


Well . . . yes and no . . . but let's not get off on that. It's just that your response, while thoughtful and not all that basic, really, came after I'd already arrived at a decision and mentioned it in the message immediately before yours. My response to your comment only further explained why I came to the conclusion I have . . . which I hope is the correct one.

And now there's another thing I'm wondering about. I wonder how long it is before a MILDC user gets used to a feeling of being underdressed because of the camera's lack of bulk? Maybe I need to develop a Leica M mentality.


Reply

cooltouch писал(а):
It's just that your response, while thoughtful and not all that basic, really, came after I'd already arrived at a decision and mentioned it in the message immediately before yours.


When you post a topic on a public forum, you make it of interest to people other than yourself. Your decision factors list was worth of a comment in my opinion, because I see a lot of new photographers
taking purchase decisions for the reasons you mentioned (brand name, list of features...), and rarely because of the use they're planning to make of the tools.
Something that often results in buyer's regrets, second hand sales, loss of money.

By the way, your aforementioned message was posted only some 18 hours after the initial post. That is a short time to call a forum reply untimely.


Reply

Orio писал(а):
By the way, your aforementioned message was posted only some 18 hours after the initial post. That is a short time to call a forum reply untimely.


But when did I call your post untimely? In fact, I referred to it as "good general advice for somebody who's just beginning to think about things regarding choosing a new system." Which seems to agree with what you've just written. So, I don't see where we disagree.


Reply

Just for the record, there are some great deals on new Nex 6 currently: http://www.sonyalpharumors.com/first-nex-6-book-and-great-nex-6-deal/ - but I guess you need to live in the US.

I was really hoping for Canon to issue a "good" MILC but both the EOS-M and Nex 6 convinced to switch to Sony and I don't regret it Very Happy A used Nex 7 would be an option, but to answer your question, the optional EVF also fits on on a Nex 3 so this can be considered - and Sony's EVF is truly great.

Adapters for Nex are widely available, incl. official ones for the Alpha lenses (incl. phase-detect AF), but also ones for EF lenses with aperture control.


Reply

Michael,
I think you are fence sitting like most of us do when considering a new move into unknown camera territory. Very Happy You can only research so much before it comes down to just buying the camera.The cameras are going nowhere, especially the ones who haven't been released yet.

You know patience is the name of the game when buying any camera or lens. Wink


Reply

Yeah, but it's the ones that haven't been released yet that always bother me! <sigh>

I know, I know. Just sitting here, typing out responses and being forced to read through specifications and features of the various models has helped a lot. Having handled the NEX series on several occasions also has helped. What I feel strangest about is moving outside the Canon comfort zone, but as I look around at what Sony is doing with the Alpha cameras and at their long-term plans, I really see a bright future there, such that I might be willing to completely switch systems some day. But for now, at least, it sure does look like the NEX 7 has it over all others. And even if I had to buy one new, it will be a price I can afford with some adjustments much sooner than buying a 6D. 5DIII, I just don't want to wait that long.


Reply

Looking at your lens list, your FD and RF glass looks much more appealing than your Canon AF glass. For me that would tip me into buying a camera capable of mounting it sooner rather than later.

So to me there would have been only one question: do I buy NEX-7 or NEX-6 now (rather expensive, but has EVF and better controls) or do I buy a really cheap body (say NEX-3/5) now and wait for FF NEX or whatever is around the corner.

Personally, I would buy NEX-3/5 and be happy. For me EVF is non-essential and NEX-5 has a great form factor that is easily jacket pocketable, so for me it has some advantages over 6/7 in addition to price. You seems to value EVF, so the logical decision might be different.