| Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема |
| Автор |
Сообщение |
Damp Cat
Зарегистрирован: 21.06.2016 Сообщения: 18
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 6:20 am Заголовок сообщения: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 6:20 am Заголовок сообщения: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
|
Damp Cat wrote:
I primarily shoot wedding films with an A7S, and need an ultra-wide on the cheap.
Which of these would be preferable?
I understand the latter is a different focal length altogether compared to the former two,
and ideally the wider I can go, the better;
but I need decent levels of sharpness without having to stop down too much,
and if that means sacrificing a bit of ultra-wide-ness then so be it.
For reference, I use a Zenitar M2s 50mm f/2.0 and a Zenitar-1N 85mm f/1.4 - so I'm looking for sharpness levels to match these lenses.
I also have a Vivitar 55mm f/2.8 1:1 macro which I do NOT use, as I find the rendering and colors of that lens to not go too well with my Zenitars
(which is kind of why I'm a bit skeptical about the Vivitar 20mm and how well I could cut its footage with my Zenitars). |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
calvin83
 Зарегистрирован: 12.04.2009 Сообщения: 7740 Откуда: Hong Kong
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 6:59 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 6:59 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
calvin83 wrote:
Old ultra-wide can be sharp in the center but not the edges until stopped down to F5.6 or beyond. The Tamron is not cheap too. _________________ The best lens is the one you have with you.
https://lensfever.com/
https://www.instagram.com/_lens_fever/ |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Gatorengineer64
 Зарегистрирован: 26.10.2017 Сообщения: 292
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 2:50 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 2:50 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Gatorengineer64 wrote:
I tried to post my first pic here but struck out.
I own the Mir-20 and the Tamron 17. The 17 is alot wider than 20mm Mir, so perhaps not the best comparison. Comparing the lenses
1) the mir has alot less "as shot" contrast than the Tamron my Mir is serial 871464, so perhaps there are later versions with better coatings, or perhaps not. There is no shortage of web pages discussing variants of russian glass.
2) Both Lens have a fair bit of CA.
3) Both lenses stopped down to 5.6 are pretty sharp
4) The Mir is very intolerant of flare, and for me this is a deal breaker for the Mir. (I was going to do what you just posted and keep one and pass one along, and the Mir will be leaving)
There is a Tokina 17mm, that many report is better than the tamron, but I dont have it to comment, you can google the comparison between the two. _________________ A7R4, GFX50R and a bucket of mflenses |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Damp Cat
Зарегистрирован: 21.06.2016 Сообщения: 18
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 4:56 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 4:56 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Damp Cat wrote:
| Gatorengineer64 писал(а): |
I tried to post my first pic here but struck out.
I own the Mir-20 and the Tamron 17. The 17 is alot wider than 20mm Mir, so perhaps not the best comparison. Comparing the lenses
1) the mir has alot less "as shot" contrast than the Tamron my Mir is serial 871464, so perhaps there are later versions with better coatings, or perhaps not. There is no shortage of web pages discussing variants of russian glass.
2) Both Lens have a fair bit of CA.
3) Both lenses stopped down to 5.6 are pretty sharp
4) The Mir is very intolerant of flare, and for me this is a deal breaker for the Mir. (I was going to do what you just posted and keep one and pass one along, and the Mir will be leaving)
There is a Tokina 17mm, that many report is better than the tamron, but I dont have it to comment, you can google the comparison between the two. |
Thanks for that! I found a variant of the Tamron 17mm locally for what it seems to be an absolute steal, so I might as well spring for that then. |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Lloydy
 Зарегистрирован: 02.09.2009 Сообщения: 7880 Откуда: Ironbridge. UK.
Expire: 2022-01-01
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 5:47 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Вс Янв 14, 2018 5:47 pm Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Lloydy wrote:
The Tokina 17 is just about my most used lens on my Sony A6000, it really is very good, but obviously edge performance doesn't count. _________________ LENSES & CAMERAS FOR SALE.....
I have loads of stuff that I have to get rid of, if you see me commenting about something I have got and you want one, ask me.
My Flickr https://www.flickr.com/photos/mudplugga/
My ipernity -
http://www.ipernity.com/home/294337 |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Lightshow
 Зарегистрирован: 04.11.2011 Сообщения: 3666 Откуда: Calgary
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 2:35 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 2:35 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Lightshow wrote:
I'd pick the Tokina, or a Nikkor 18/4, I love my CV15III
Mir 20
Nikkor 18/4
https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/tags/nikkor184ai/
CV15III
https://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/tags/cv15iii/
 _________________ A Manual Focus Junky...
One photographers junk lens is an artists favorite tool.
My lens list
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/ |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
TrueLoveOne
 Зарегистрирован: 30.09.2012 Сообщения: 1839 Откуда: Netherlands
Expire: 2013-12-24
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 5:52 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 5:52 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
TrueLoveOne wrote:
I happen to have both the Tamron and the Tokina. On crop both lenses are excellent performers. The Tamron however is the better lens on FF.
See my topic on the Tokina, which show quite some differences between left and right edges. The lens is not aligned very well, it also seemed as if i am not the only one with that problem.
However: i enjoy using the Tokina more than i do the Tamron. Can't really explain this, but the Tamron seems more "clinical" if that makes any sense....
Topic here: http://forum.mflenses.com/rmc-tokina-3-5-17-on-sony-a7-t73884,highlight,%2Btokina+%2B17m.html
And a sample on a Canon 5D (Tokina 17mm):
Drama in the air by René Maly, on Flickr
Cheers, René! _________________ My Flickr photostream: http://www.flickr.com/photos/chantalrene/
Sony A7, Canon 5D mkII, Minolta 7D + RD3000 and some more.....
Minolta and Konica collector.... slowly selling all the other stuff! |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Mr G
 Зарегистрирован: 27.01.2014 Сообщения: 187 Откуда: London & Essex
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 7:49 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 7:49 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Mr G wrote:
I wouldn't shy away from the Viv's, as everybody here knows copies can vary depending on maker, they use some fine glass and provide superb results. _________________ EVEN A BLIND SQUIRREL FINDS A NUT NOW AND THEN! |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
Lightshow
 Зарегистрирован: 04.11.2011 Сообщения: 3666 Откуда: Calgary
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 8:36 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 8:36 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
Lightshow wrote:
I can't test the Mir 20 anymore, I lent it to a friend, and haven't seen him in a number of years since, in this pic I was trying to focus on the ducks. _________________ A Manual Focus Junky...
One photographers junk lens is an artists favorite tool.
My lens list
http://www.flickr.com/photos/lightshow-photography/ |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
caspert79
 Зарегистрирован: 31.10.2010 Сообщения: 3911 Откуда: The Netherlands
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 11:38 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 11:38 am Заголовок сообщения: |
|
|
caspert79 wrote:
I love the Tokina 17/3.5. Sharp, contrasty and almost no distortion. I used it on my Oly OM-4; great lens. |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
PBFACTS
 Зарегистрирован: 24.12.2008 Сообщения: 592
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 11:52 am Заголовок сообщения: Re: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
 Отправлено: Чт Мар 29, 2018 11:52 am Заголовок сообщения: Re: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
|
PBFACTS wrote:
| Damp Cat писал(а): |
I primarily shoot wedding films with an A7S, and need an ultra-wide on the cheap.
Which of these would be preferable?
I understand the latter is a different focal length altogether compared to the former two,
and ideally the wider I can go, the better;
but I need decent levels of sharpness without having to stop down too much,
and if that means sacrificing a bit of ultra-wide-ness then so be it.
|
If you go to ultra-wide, you can look at the Sigma 14mm 3.5 which did exists in both af and mf (i have the om version) version
Quality is ok / Distortion very low
[/img]https://omexperience.wordpress.com/lenses/sigma-14mm-f3-5/[img][/img][img]
ps : these are scans from film in medium resolution (not top res) _________________ OM USER .. I KEEP/USE:
Om2 sp + T32 (grip/filter/zoom) + T8
+ Zuiko 16mm 3.5 / 55mm 1.2 / 65-200 4/ x1.4
+ Sigma 8mm 4.0 / 14mm 3.5 / 18-35 3.5-4.5
+ Tamron 35/105 2.8
+Tokina 150/500 5.6
+ Kiron 105/2.8 macro 1:1
+ Vivitar S1 90/180 falst field macro
+ 2x Doubler HR7
>>I SELL: OM10 + OM4ti
+ i sell: OM Md1 + Md 2 + Grip PowerPack + charger
+ i sell: OM Zuiko 24mm 2.8 / 28mm 3.5 / 50mm 1.8 / 50mm 1.4 / 50mm 3.5 macro / 35-70 3.6 / 35-105 3.5-4.5 / 75-150 4 / 500mm / 2xA
+ i sell: OM Kiron 28/105 3.2-4.5 / 1.5 converter
+ i sell: OM Makinon reflex 5.6/300 + Spector reflex (makinon) 500mm
+ i sell: OM Macro panagor extender 1:1
+ i sell: OM Sigma 16mm 2.8 fisheye (last version) / 21-35 3.5-4.2 ot/ 28-70 2.8 /1000mm mirror
+ i sell: Tamron 28-70 3.5-4.5 / 28-80 sp 3.5-4.2 / 28-135 sp 4-4.5 / /28-200 3.5 / 35-135 3..5-4.5 / 90mm sp macro 1:1 2.8
+ i sell: OM Soligor 2x doubler / x3 converte
+ i sell: Soligor FisheEye x0.15
+ i sell: OM Tokina 28/135 4-4.6 / 70/210 3.5 (= vivitar S1 v2)
+ i sell: OM Vivitar 28-70 3.5-4.8 / 28-90 s1 2.8-3.5 / 35-70 2.8-3.8 / 55/2.8 Macro 1:1 (komine) / 70-150 3.8 ot (kiron) / 75-150 ot 3.8 (tokina + 2x matched)
+ i sell : OM cosina 100-500 5.6/8 |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
cooltouch
 Зарегистрирован: 15.01.2009 Сообщения: 9096 Откуда: Houston, Texas
|
 Отправлено: Пт Мар 30, 2018 12:49 am Заголовок сообщения: Re: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
 Отправлено: Пт Мар 30, 2018 12:49 am Заголовок сообщения: Re: MIR-20 vs. Vivitar 20mm 3.8 vs. Tamron/Tokina 17mm 3.5 |
|
|
cooltouch wrote:
| Damp Cat писал(а): |
I primarily shoot wedding films with an A7S, and need an ultra-wide on the cheap.
Which of these would be preferable?
I understand the latter is a different focal length altogether compared to the former two,
and ideally the wider I can go, the better;
but I need decent levels of sharpness without having to stop down too much,
and if that means sacrificing a bit of ultra-wide-ness then so be it.
For reference, I use a Zenitar M2s 50mm f/2.0 and a Zenitar-1N 85mm f/1.4 - so I'm looking for sharpness levels to match these lenses.
I also have a Vivitar 55mm f/2.8 1:1 macro which I do NOT use, as I find the rendering and colors of that lens to not go too well with my Zenitars
(which is kind of why I'm a bit skeptical about the Vivitar 20mm and how well I could cut its footage with my Zenitars). |
I have a Vivitar 17mm f/3.5, made by Tokina, in Canon FD mount. I've used it with film cameras only prior to buying my NEX 7, but I've found that my NEX doesn't care for this lens too much. Images I get with it are just so-so.
I also own a Tamron 17mm f/3.5 and I've also had good luck with it with film cameras. Unfortunately, same as the Vivitar, my NEX doesn't care for it. Images are just so-so. It has to do with the way the rays are bent with these lenses and the angle they impact the sensors.
But this shouldn't affect you since you have a FF A7S. I've found both the Tamron and the Vivitar to be reasonably sharp to the corners with my film cameras.
Another lens that comes to mind that you might want to consider, not quite as wide, but an outstanding optic, is the Nikon 20mm f/3.5 UD. It's an older lens, but it is a good one. As far as that goes, I reckon the later model Nikon 20mm's will be good as well. _________________ Michael
My Gear List: http://michaelmcbroom.com/photo/gear.html
My Gallery: http://michaelmcbroom.com/gallery3/index.php/
My Flickr Page: https://www.flickr.com/photos/11308754@N08/albums
My Music: https://soundcloud.com/michaelmcbroom/albums
My Blog: http://michaelmcbroom.com/blogistan/ |
|
| Наверх |
|
 |
|
|
|
Вы не можете создавать новые темы в этом форуме Вы не можете отвечать в темах этого форума Вы не можете редактировать свои сообщения в этом форуме Вы не можете удалять свои сообщения в этом форуме Вы не можете голосовать в опросах этого форума
|