MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

35mm Landscape Recommendations
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

I need/want a new 35mm lens for landscape! I moved to Colorado, USA a little over a year ago and want a new landscape lens to play with. My go to 35mm landscape lens right now is a Leica Elmarit R which is a fantastic lens, but HEAVY. I'm looking to shed some weight for hiking and the like. Camera body I use is a Sony A7 IV and I have a bunch of adapters. Let me know what you guys/gals would recommend!


Reply

Minolta MD 35mm f/2.8 is all you need.


Reply

caspert79 писал(а):
Minolta MD 35mm f/2.8 is all you need.


Agreed; however most of the 2nd generation 2.8/35mm lenses (around 1980) of the well known manufacturers are very good.

A few years ago I have compared a few 2.8/35mm lenses side-by-side:
https://forum.mflenses.com/test-nione-vintage-2-8-35mm-lenses-on-24-mp-ff-t82723.html

MAKE SURE TO CLICK TWICE ON THE TESTIMAGE, DOWNLOAD THE ORIGINAL FILE AND LOOK AT IT AT 100% USING A DECENT SOFTWARE SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP!

While not included in the above test, I have a Leica Elmarit R 2.8/35mm as well, and tomorrow I could compare it to the Minolta MD-III 2.8/35mm if you want. That should give you a good idea about its performance for landscapes.

S


Reply

why might vintage lens A be considered "better" than vintage lens B in certain situations..
and what about the rest of lenses - from C to Z ..?

anyway, as far as i have tried a few (standard/vintage), nothing beats the versatility and portability of konica ar 40 / 1.8.
even on apc-s.
and as you write you are probably looking for a compromise


Reply

My personal experience in that field showed to me that for landscape the best lens would be 40-43mm.

35 mm is for that purpose little too wide, in terms of perspective of the final image.

So, I would recommend Voigtlander Nokton Classic 40mm f/1.4

https://www.kylecongphotography.com/blog/voigtlander-nokton-classic-40mm-f14-lens-review





Or - also very nice for that purpose Konica Hexanon Ar 40mm F 1.8


Reply

Another vote for the Konica Hexanon 40mm f/1.8 ... mine is in regular use.
For something just that little bit wider ... a Meyer-Optik 30mm f/3.5 Lydith - there's a reason there's been two attempts in recent years to revive it, mine is an "original".

For reference, the Hexanon weighs 140gm, the Lydith weighs 188gm (in M42 mount).


Reply

kypfer писал(а):
Another vote for the Konica Hexanon 40mm f/1.8 ... mine is in regular use.
For something just that little bit wider ... a Meyer-Optik 30mm f/3.5 Lydith - there's a reason there's been two attempts in recent years to revive it, mine is an "original".

For reference, the Hexanon weighs 140gm, the Lydith weighs 188gm (in M42 mount).


Lydith would be in my book not a versatile option as for me it works in some aspects .. but its interesting u have mentioned - i have to take it out once again, its been a long time.
The irritating part is m42 adapter, that makes aps-c not light and portable gear.

I would like to know if there are 'lighter' adapters too, its ridiculous to have 2mm wall thickness for wide/normal lenses.

Back to Hexanon: any of lenses would be a perfect choice and only one adapter. However older metal 28mm is not the lightest lens.


Reply

For landscape you are looking for maximum resolution and micro-contrast. The Minolta MD 35 2,8 @5,6 will provide you with all that better than all lenses I have used.

If you are looking for slightly longer focal length the MD 45 2,0 @6,7 is perfect.

The 35 more open will remain sharp but will lose some micro-contrast you can recover in post. The 45 will lose resolution on corners mainly due to field curvature but f2,0 should be avoided.


Reply

Another one to consider: the Yashica ML 35mm f/2.8. Not as common or well-known as the Minolta, but excellent corner-to-corner from F/4 with lovely colors and rendering. Build quality is significantly better than the Minolta, too.

A lot of C/Y shooters actually prefer the Yashica to the much more expensive C/Y Distagon of the same specs.


Reply

I have a Konica 40mm on the way but still want to try one more. I have yet to try Minolta lenses, but it might be time to take the dive. I'm a bit worried it might lead to other Minolta lenses though, like I need more! Lol

Keep the suggestions coming!


Reply

BrianSVP писал(а):
Another one to consider: the Yashica ML 35mm f/2.8. Not as common or well-known as the Minolta, but excellent corner-to-corner from F/4 with lovely colors and rendering. Build quality is significantly better than the Minolta, too.

A lot of C/Y shooters actually prefer the Yashica to the much more expensive C/Y Distagon of the same specs.


i had the zeiss c/y excellent lens, just so perfect, but i sold it because it wasn´t my best focal length i´ve needed, meantime i bought a cheapn MC flek 2.4 and yashica ml (like new cctv sticker on it), unfortunately one of the element haze affected so cannot rely on proper results, but mechanically seems the same or very close to zeiss. By the praises , the MD III version might be on pair with zeiss, but in my case, the 1.8 version is fitting much better (not for landscapes).


Reply

mr_tibbs2004 писал(а):
I have a Konica 40mm on the way but still want to try one more. I have yet to try Minolta lenses, but it might be time to take the dive. I'm a bit worried it might lead to other Minolta lenses though, like I need more! Lol

Keep the suggestions coming!


01 - Make a choice about how much money you want to spend,
02 - Go to your preferred source for old lenses,
03 - Buy anything within your financial range,
04 - Go on your hike and use the lens(es),
05 - Come back to this forum with a report on what you learned about the lenses or photography, and maybe even about hiking (Colorado? i wonder how you gonna hike during the winter..),
06 - a lens no good no ..? sell it and get another one.
07 - create strong stories and share it. Works best while consuming some some strong drinks.
08 - rinse and repeat


Reply

Now using something via the mail adapter has come to naught. For Sony, there are tamron 35/2.8, samyang, 7Artisans 35/1.4 mk3


Reply

sergun писал(а):
Now using something via the mail adapter has come to naught. For Sony, there are tamron 35/2.8, samyang, 7Artisans 35/1.4 mk3

I've got rid of the c/y Zeiss 35mm 2.8 because it was way too perfect lol, so I guess it has to do a lot with the expectations each one of us have from a specific lens -probably modern lenses might be the best (cheaper also) for clinically perfect pictures


Reply

kiddo писал(а):
sergun писал(а):
Now using something via the mail adapter has come to naught. For Sony, there are tamron 35/2.8, samyang, 7Artisans 35/1.4 mk3

I've got rid of the c/y Zeiss 35mm 2.8 because it was way too perfect lol, so I guess it has to do a lot with the expectations each one of us have from a specific lens -probably modern lenses might be the best (cheaper also) for clinically perfect pictures

The MTF don't look too perfect for me although it is probably one of the best of its time. I do agree it is better to get the 'right one' rather than a 'perfect' one.


Reply

calvin83 писал(а):
kiddo писал(а):
sergun писал(а):
Now using something via the mail adapter has come to naught. For Sony, there are tamron 35/2.8, samyang, 7Artisans 35/1.4 mk3

I've got rid of the c/y Zeiss 35mm 2.8 because it was way too perfect lol, so I guess it has to do a lot with the expectations each one of us have from a specific lens -probably modern lenses might be the best (cheaper also) for clinically perfect pictures

The MTF don't look too perfect for me although it is probably one of the best of its time. I do agree it is better to get the 'right one' rather than a 'perfect' one.


well, ``too perfect`` for me was comparing it with minolta 1.8 or topcor 2.8 (early version)


Reply

mr_tibbs2004 писал(а):
I need/want a new 35mm lens for landscape! I moved to Colorado, USA a little over a year ago and want a new landscape lens to play with. My go to 35mm landscape lens right now is a Leica Elmarit R which is a fantastic lens, but HEAVY. I'm looking to shed some weight for hiking and the like. Camera body I use is a Sony A7 IV and I have a bunch of adapters. Let me know what you guys/gals would recommend!


Mamiya Sekor CS or E/EF 35mm 2.8
I guess the Topcor Auto 35mm 2.8 would not be bad either, no experience with that one.
Both light (with a light adapter).



Reply

I have experience with the RE version of the Topcor and can vouch that it's a fine landscape lens.

Ernst Dinkla писал(а):
mr_tibbs2004 писал(а):
I need/want a new 35mm lens for landscape! I moved to Colorado, USA a little over a year ago and want a new landscape lens to play with. My go to 35mm landscape lens right now is a Leica Elmarit R which is a fantastic lens, but HEAVY. I'm looking to shed some weight for hiking and the like. Camera body I use is a Sony A7 IV and I have a bunch of adapters. Let me know what you guys/gals would recommend!


Mamiya Sekor CS or E/EF 35mm 2.8
I guess the Topcor Auto 35mm 2.8 would not be bad either, no experience with that one.
Both light (with a light adapter).



Reply

Here, for reference, my older test published again:



(CLICK TWICE ON THE IMAGE TO GET THE FULL RESOLUTION PIC, AND PREFERRABLY LOOK AT IT USING A SOFTWARE SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP)

The difference between 1st gen 2.8/35mm lenses and their later 2nd gen counterparts is pretty obvious.

s


Reply

Ernst Dinkla писал(а):


Mamiya Sekor CS or E/EF 35mm 2.8
I guess the Topcor Auto 35mm 2.8 would not be bad either, no experience with that one.
Both light (with a light adapter).


I'm very open to trying the Mamiya! I have a 55mm f1.8 that I love to use. Great suggestion! I will have to wait to try one out for a bit though as I also ordered a Minolta MD 35mm that is on the way along with the Konica 40mm. The Topcor looks like a great lens as well, but alas that's another adapter I would have to purchase.


Reply

My own experience with the Topcor doesn't jibe with what's showing here, and I'm wondering if you got a bad copy. The MD and the Yashica unsurprisingly both look great.
That said, there's a lot more to a landscape lens (or any type of lens, for that matter) than just the corners anyway, and the Topcor produces a beautiful look that is very distinct form either of those two.

stevemark писал(а):
Here, for reference, my older test published again:



(CLICK TWICE ON THE IMAGE TO GET THE FULL RESOLUTION PIC, AND PREFERRABLY LOOK AT IT USING A SOFTWARE SUCH AS PHOTOSHOP)

The difference between 1st gen 2.8/35mm lenses and their later 2nd gen counterparts is pretty obvious.

s


Reply

BrianSVP писал(а):
My own experience with the Topcor doesn't jibe with what's showing here, and I'm wondering if you got a bad copy.

Could you post three 100% crop from the corners of a 24MP FF camera, taken with YOUR Topcor RE 2.8/35mm? Ans indicate the corresponding SN as well? That would sort it out pretty quickly!

Interestingly, I have seen similar differences (most probably NOT copy-to-copy variation) between A) the older Konica AR 2.8/35mm [7L] with metal focusing grip and B) the newer Konica AR 2.8/35mm [7L] with rubber focusing grip (not talking about the latest AR 2.8/35mm [5L] here!), as shown in my test images above. Of course I did suspect a bad copy first, but testing three copies of the earlier "full metal" AR 2.8/35mm revealed that all of them were much worse copared to the later "rubber grip" version. BTW the published lens sections for both theses are identical ...

So we might have somehow different computations with the Topcor RE 2.8/35mm as well, especially since such variations are well documented for the RE 1.8/58mm (and for other lenses such as the Nikkor-S 2.8/35mm, of course).



BrianSVP писал(а):
The MD and the Yashica unsurprisingly both look great.

The same is true for the latest Konica AR 2.8/35mm [5L] and the Mamiya EF 2.8/35mm, which I only got after doing the above test.


BrianSVP писал(а):
That said, there's a lot more to a landscape lens (or any type of lens, for that matter) than just the corners anyway, and the Topcor produces a beautiful look that is very distinct form either of those two.

Sure. I certainly would welcome others to document those differences from their point of view, by doing side-by-side comparisons!! Sadly quite a few people here promised to do so, but I've never seen these promises materializing ... Too much work, I assume ... ?!?

S


Reply

stevemark писал(а):


So we might have somehow different computations with the Topcor RE 2.8/35mm as well, especially since such variations are well documented for the RE 1.8/58mm (and for other lenses such as the Nikkor-S 2.8/35mm, of course). S


I had a beater copy of the above nikkor "S", and it performed admirably well for what it was- an older 35mm.
Although not a corners performer in the modern sense, it did the landscape thing quite reasonably.

Sample images here:

https://forum.mflenses.com/nikkor-s-35mm-f-2-8-t84160.html

I'd like to get another "cleaner" copy one of these days. The one I had seemed to be nicely (for the period) corrected for distortion as well.

-D.S.


Reply

Doc Sharptail писал(а):

I had a beater copy of the above nikkor "S", and it performed admirably well for what it was- an older 35mm.
Although not a corners performer in the modern sense, it did the landscape thing quite reasonably.

...

-D.S.


Yeah, I agree on that.

I have two copies of the 2nd optical computation of the Nikkor-S 2.8/35mm (1962), and for a 1960s retrofocus 2.8/35mm lens it's surprisingly good indeed. Not on the level of the [5/5] version of the Minolta 2.8/35mm (released staring in 1977 as the MD-I), but better than most contemporary 2.8/35mm lenses for sure.

History of the 2.8/35mm Nikkors here in the Nikon website, told by Kouichi Ohshita, a leading Nikon lens designer:
https://imaging.nikon.com/imaging/information/story/0038/

S


Reply

A couple of photos taken with the Minolta MD today. I'm VERY happy with the initial results! This was a new drive the wife and I took today that we will be repeating. I'll try the Konica next time out!