MFlenses — новая жизнь в цифровую эпоху
MFLenses 2026

Форум объективов с ручной фокусировкой

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.

Исследуйте мир старых объективов через заметки о ремонте, реальные тестовые снимки и подробные архивные темы с множеством изображений.
В центре внимания

Место для партнёра на главной странице форума.

which is better?
Предыдущая тема :: Следующая тема  


Reply

The first shot is the original one I posted and the second is a new way using
far fewer tools out of the Adobe toolbox. Would like to know which you
prefer, and why. Thanks.




and another using this newer minimalist method:


All from the same camera and film (OM-2/Arista Premium 400/HC-110B)


Последний раз редактировалось Katastrofo Вт Сен 28, 2010 1:42 pm; всего правок: 1


Reply

It is difficult to say Bill, because one thing is the B&W on screen, another is the B&W printed.

Personally on-screen I appreciate the wider range of greys in the second photo, but I'm pretty sure that when printing inkjet from a digital file, the deeper blacks and higher contrast of the first image will have something to say.

I also like the last image.


Reply

Orio, appreciate your insights. I much prefer the second version onscreen,
more detail in the shadows, some reduction in grain, and smoother tones.
Photos tend to come out darker when printing with inkjet and reworked
this one without using SEP:



More catchlight and detail in the eyes as well


Reply

I don't see enough difference to justify a more complicated workflow.


Reply

I like the first one...I never really look at the shadows unless you guys are talking about it.If you look at the first ones hair and pony tail area it looks so much more natural, the light rolls around that area...if that makes sense.This is of course looking at the images before me on a computer screen I would be unsure what the differences would be if they were printed out in front of me on paper.


Reply

I prefer the contrast and the character of noise/grain in the 1st one.

The 2nd lacks a bit of bite.


Reply

The difference between the 2 is more visible on the back of the hair, 1st is a bit darker, i prefer it.


Reply

Well on my screen there is more grain and contrast in the first one...the contrast probably makes the shot look sharper as well?

..........for an older woman (for example) I would prefer the 2nd shot.


Reply

Speaking of negatives (I know this isn't negatives), the second image would be a much more flexible negative to print in any way you want, contrasted or not, depending on paper and developer. While the first image would be a less good negative because you have less middle information and so you would be more or less forced to print with contrast.

Speaking of inkjet printing instead, I always found that images with robust contrast print more appealing than images with moderate contrast.


Reply

Hi Bill: I like the on-screen look of the 2nd image; it seems more "fluid"
somehow, if that makes any sense.

Regardless of the differences between #1 and #2, either one SHOULD be
printed up. The imagery is superb.


Reply

Folks, thanks for your advice and kind comments! What got me started on
this is the patchy areas along her neck in the first, I didn't like it. The 2nd
is way closer to the smooth tonal gradations I was after, my preference,
over sharpness. I'll keep experimenting, I think if I upped the contrast I'd
be very close to the first, but without using 4 additional tools to get there.
I'll be working on many files after the upcoming wedding and keeping it
simple in the post-processing stage will be a real boon.

Thanks again.


Reply

Not that my eyes can be trusted by anyone - including me - I have to agree with Orio's analysis ...


Reply

fish4570 писал(а):
Not that my eyes can be trusted by anyone - including me - I have to agree with Orio's analysis ...


Yes, agree, printing from an inkjet, the higher contrast will definitely be
better. I don't think I'm going to be happy until I can do my own wet prints
from negatives at home. Still pondering the logistics of that...